Repository navigation
Bound the PR5580 κ .0033 budget and ideal isolated-tail edit counts - #5592
Merged
Mister-Meeseeks merged 1 commit intoOct 25, 2026
Merged
Mister-Meeseeks merged 1 commit into
Mister-Meeseeks merged 1 commit into
Conversation
Contributor
Author
Seven-field research handoff
The raw/derived source RESULT serializations and explicit custody revision are retained. Current context: PR #5590 reports a fixed-contact price floor; it is distinct from this favorable inventory relaxation and was not replayed here. Discussion5575 owns the specified commuting-ADD/frame work; 5125 owns joint basis splitting. Coordinate before any constructive follow-up. This completed finding reserves no source/contact search. {"schema":"integer-mult-coordination/v1","kind":"FINDING","task":"scalar-to-moment","scope":"Exact PR5580 two-point analytic budget and 146/147 strict-single-use isolated-tail histogram minima; no actual contacts, no funded kappa","base":"32890bc5de034ab8fc93ac88ead7279a6a416d04","expiry":null,"artifact":"https://github.com/CrocSwap/integer-mult-bounds/pull/5592"} |
This file contains hidden or bidirectional Unicode text that may be interpreted or compiled differently than what appears below. To review, open the file in an editor that reveals hidden Unicode characters.
Learn more about bidirectional Unicode characters
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.This suggestion is invalid because no changes were made to the code.Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is closed.Suggestions cannot be applied while viewing a subset of changes.Only one suggestion per line can be applied in a batch.Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.Applying suggestions on deleted lines is not supported.You must change the existing code in this line in order to create a valid suggestion.Outdated suggestions cannot be applied.This suggestion has been applied or marked resolved.Suggestions cannot be applied from pending reviews.Suggestions cannot be applied on multi-line comments.Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is queued to merge.Suggestion cannot be applied right now. Please check back later.
Change and mathematical scope
This composite adds a historical exact PR #5569 price certificate and a separate current PR #5580 analytic transfer/count certificate. For exact PR #5580 head$C=.0033$ and $C=.0033000005$ .
6efa248cf456d6101d757e9d09ba29711d18a13a, the optimistic strict-single-use isolated-tail class needs at least 146 ideal exchanges per FULL with the permitted controller law, or 147 with the submitted 18-FULL caller retained, atThe source paid change is$C=.0033$ :
+H2−2H3+H4per FULL, with targets unchanged. The current certificate transfers the authenticated PR #5569 B/J intervals throughB5580=B5569−gD, wheregD=2H3−H2−H4. AtThe count proof charges the productive rank loss of every isolated tail. Granted multiset witnesses use 94H4+52H5 for 146/n17 and 94H4+53H5 for 147/n18, with complete paid/target/surplus 60604/12079/712 and 64206/12814/760. Their complete raw slack is positive but below one global H1; an added uncompensated global H1 defeats these particular witnesses. Every query, whole idle and main bank is charged. Ordinary costs and compiler reserve remain separate.
This is an exact two-point necessary-budget/count result in an explicitly optimistic accounting class. It finds no actual 146/147 contacts, establishes no compatible source edits, constructs no 17-call caller, certifies no new funded κ and changes no selected result. Frame/endpoint/native, uniform precision/tape and complete compiler/outer premises remain open. Balanced concavity and the PR #5554 all-n implication are paper arguments, not a proof-kernel theorem. There is no larger-C or general P104 ceiling claim.
Task and overlap
Publication head
c8b49410fb31d107d8c85d160ac5ca737c403231, tested tree7e102b38d64ca97c43f0648ac8e275a3918ed111, directly based on32890bc5de034ab8fc93ac88ead7279a6a416d04. Current upstream main5e0052ca0aa3036a3afa8b0438927377c8d97d53and guidance were checked separately at the 21:09 UTC prepublication checkpoint. Both package byte sets and source history were checked against the exact remote commit; 87 files are added.Task
scalar-to-moment, priority revision 7, changed scope. The original construction-gain gate is not met. The useful contribution is a current complete aggregate budget that prevents one attractive isolated contact from being mistaken for a complete .0033 route.research/p104-successor-price-gate: immutable 37-file historical PR #5569 certificate at headaf9f091ac6f30c6eaacb9c27777bfbe2d0e5ffdf.research/p104-current-tail-count: separate current certificate for Ali Romman's PR5580, exact head6efa248cf456d6101d757e9d09ba29711d18a13a.GamingPuzzled's PR #5569/PR #5472 supply the predecessor handoff/cost lineage; zxv's PR #5554 supplies the all-controller reduction. PR #5585's native work is distinct from this price/count artifact. PR #5579's fixed-anchor owned holder obstruction is tied to its PR #5561/PR #5569 sources and does not transfer automatically to PR #5580's changed anchor. Constructive inventories remain outside this package. A broader A/B/C/D accounting family is under separate paper assessment, outside isolated tails; no resulting theorem or physical composition is claimed here. No exhaustive novelty claim is made.
Validation
Original current qualification: one root-reviewed normal/optimized pair, 0.905806529 seconds and 63,401,984 bytes sampled descendant RSS under the unchanged 150 second / 512 MiB serial guard. All 25 classified controls rejected and every scientific output byte matched, with zero exclusions. Result:
f0ab2ed10f91a5acd76c1c6753d970c59e51e83c3d0b96fe8a6a3a6c3f80e9de.The current wrapper preserves check.py, finite.py, request, inputs, both results and guard/log byte for byte. It authenticates every package/input byte, executes only the current finite certificate in an isolated private child limited to 60 seconds / 512 MiB, compares complete original output, then reauthenticates. It imports no price engine, source constructor or native module. Both source RESULT serializations and their explicit custody revision are retained; the historical derived hash was not silently replaced by the exact author-text hash.
Current-package commands:
Expected marker:
PASS_P104_CURRENT_TAIL_COUNT. The historical package retains its own registered reproduction command and evidence unchanged; its science is not rerun as part of this static preparation.Portable current normal/-O registered replay passed in 1.714 seconds, sampled 88.61 MiB, under the unchanged 150 seconds / 512 MiB guard. Separate read-only Git-free optimized export with spaces and empty PATH passed in .705 seconds, sampled 63.70 MiB; all 51 exported files remained unchanged. Three custody corruptions reject before science in both modes. Metadata and 50-file exact committed-byte/history checks passed.
The historical component independently passed its portable registered pair in 1.912 seconds, sampled 73.89 MiB, and read-only optimized export in .906 seconds, sampled 48.84 MiB; all 38 exported files remained unchanged. Its 37 scientific-package files are preserved exactly. Local checks are scoped; hosted CI is pending at submission.
The three portable source/result/raw-serialization corruptions use
--integrity-onlyand must reject before science. Export execution should use read-only files, empty PATH, an absolute interpreter and complete before/after file hashes.VERIFY.inputs=[]is intentional: all runtime source bytes are inside each package, so no machine-local path is declared as a repository input.Credit
Ali Romman for PR #5580/PR #5579 and PR #5544/PR #5545; zxv for PR #5554; GamingPuzzled for PR #5472/PR #5569; DreamingOfClouds for PR #5561/PR #5553 and tooling; thu-nmrc for PR #5551; Matarener's endpoint contract; Clear1nsight's original caller/native/price audits; all retained P104/native/controller/compiler/precision predecessors. The historical numerical engine retains its original authorship and notices; the current certificate imports no engine. Paper analysis, finite qualification and packaging for Chris R/Clear1nsight used substantial OpenAI Codex assistance. Apache-2.0. Root agent code/proof review and two-mode reproduction do not constitute independent human/formal acceptance.
Open next questions
See both packages' NEXT.md, especially
research/p104-current-tail-count/NEXT.md. A physical proposal must supply distinct actual helper/terminal-MOVE IDs, legal source windows/charts, ownership, compatibility, all changed paid/target/ordinary costs and compiler reserves. Aggregate ideal counts alone are insufficient. Broader A/B/C/D economics need a separately defined complete family and review. Independent human/formal review of the retained analytic implications is useful; no construction or contact scan is dispatched by this publication.Current overlap/context: PR5590, head
627160c5e39501b69603c3a1e03bbfdc50a53a86, reports a sharp price floor for fixed scalar contacts and arbitrary frame paths on PR #5580. We have not replayed that proof. It is distinct from this explicitly optimistic inventory class, which grants contacts/attachments and does not assert physical realization. Discussion5575 now owns the specified commuting-ADD/order plus intermediate-frame optimization; Discussion5125 owns joint input/output basis splitting. A future constructive task must coordinate with those owners; this publication reserves no contact search.