| Criterion |
Interpretation |
Planned ops |
Proof method |
Residual risk |
| skill-audit-disclosure CI check failed shortly after PR #1984 was opened for a references/**-only file |
Task 1's diff touched skills/evaluating-skill-quality/references/skill-metadata.schema.json, which independently triggers skill-audit-disclosure's applicability per issue #1796's own references-only-trigger rule, but the PR body's initial Skill audit evidence section did not yet disclose it; CI caught the gap after the PR was already open. A batched review-persona read of hooks/check-pr-skill-audit-disclosure.sh confirmed the create-time hook is capable of reproducing this exact CI verdict when it fires with an explicit base, but executing-a-branch-plan opens the PR before later waves' task commits land, and those land via a plain main-thread git push, never a second create/update_pull_request call -- so nothing re-fires the hook against the PR's growing diff until CI reacts. This is the same underlying gap open umbrella issue #1800 (skill-audit-disclosure post-push re-check gap) already tracks, and closed-duplicate #1626 already named for this PR's own creation-time variant of it. |
See #1800's own Planned ops (a post-push/re-open re-check of the PR body's Skill audit evidence section against the diff's current touched-file set, run locally before CI has to catch it). |
implementing PR adds the check plus a regression test; confirm it fails against a reintroduced instance of the original defect, then passes |
None beyond what #1800 already discloses. |
Refs #2001
Dedup-sweep: 125 open gate-proposal issues at 2026-09-14T03:57:29Z; verdict DUPLICATE-OF #1800
Refs #2001
Dedup-sweep: 125 open gate-proposal issues at 2026-09-14T03:57:29Z; verdict DUPLICATE-OF #1800