Skip to content

Correct deep-review paper evidence semantics - #91

Open
sauravsingla wants to merge 12 commits into
mainfrom
paper-deep-review-corrections-20260917
Open

sauravsingla wants to merge 12 commits into
mainfrom
paper-deep-review-corrections-20260917

Conversation

@sauravsingla

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

This PR applies the evidence-backed corrections from the final deep review without changing the frozen selector or experimental outputs.

Key corrections:

  • fixes GraphBolt operation-fraction labels from 0.01%/0.1%/0.5% to the generator-defined 0.1%/1%/5%;
  • corrects the historical false_full interpretation: the 33 labels are explicit-full/non-fallback cases, not wrong-arm or proven slower-full cases;
  • records that all six 0.35 fallback events occur in the declared 220K cascade stress case and that the 72 real-graph observations have zero such fallbacks;
  • adds retained-artifact cumulative latency results (42.7% reduction overall, 42.2% on real graphs) and guards them in the submission validator;
  • replaces the dangling “exactness theorem” wording with an exactness contract and adds a compact BFS correctness invariant;
  • makes the frozen selector mechanics more explicit in the manuscript;
  • advances the immutable submission-freeze contract to pvldb-2027-submission-v3 so the corrected manuscript can be archived without moving v2.

No post-result retuning is performed. The existing author affiliation block is intentionally not guessed or fabricated; final institutional/independent affiliation remains a factual author-supplied submission field.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant