You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
{{ message }}
Repository navigation
Switching between list types is not possible anymore #3256
Switching between bullet and numbered list seems to work fine for me.
"Only" issue seems to be switching between checkbox and the other two list types in either way.
When on a checkbox list the other two list types are greyed out. So looks like tiptap already thinks it cannot do this.
I don't remember how this was fixed after the tiptap2 migration but i remember discussing it at length in a tiptap issue: ueberdosis/tiptap#2428
The problem seems that some commands are reported as not possible by $editor.can() even though they can be used without problems. E.g. switching from a bullet list to either of ordered list (Ctrl-Shift-7), check list (Ctrl-Shift-9) or blockquote (Ctrl-Shift-B) works well via keyboard shortcuts, even though e.g. $editor.can().toggleOrderedList() returns false, leading to the corresponding menu action being disabled.
We or tiptap either would need to switch to a shared item node type or maybe could rework the command to not only change the list type but also the list item types. Haven't looked further on what would be the best or lowest effort approach.
The problem seems that some commands are reported as not possible by $editor.can() even though they can be used without problems. E.g. switching from a bullet list to either of ordered list (Ctrl-Shift-7), check list (Ctrl-Shift-9) or blockquote (Ctrl-Shift-B) works well via keyboard shortcuts, even though e.g. $editor.can().toggleOrderedList() returns false, leading to the corresponding menu action being disabled.
So it is possible to do it with a shortcut but the menu can't do it? That's very confusing 🥲
It's a bit of a frequent annoyance so I'm going to try to learn the shortcuts then, I'm very happy with the shortcut overview in that regard. Makes it easy.
Just saw this, weeks after creating #8112. I think my issue is kind of a duplicate of this one, so I will comment here, feel free to close #8112 if you agree 👍 Also, I don't fully understand the previous analysis you all did on this issue, so I thought I just describe what I see and you can happily ignore it, if says what you figured out previously 😬
First, switching between all types of lists works, if:
you switch off the current type
open the menu again
select the desired type
There seems no option to changes list types directly, no matter from which/to which type. As said by you before, shortcuts work fine.
I think this is a rather famous papercut among users, too :)
Crazy news, but apparently this got fixed 🎉 Most likely it happened with the upgrade to Tiptap v3. I can no longer reproduce this issue in Nextcloud 33 and above.
Crazy news, but apparently this got fixed 🎉 Most likely it happened with the upgrade to Tiptap v3. I can no longer reproduce this issue in Nextcloud 33 and above.
Yes, I can now directly change between ordered-, and unordered lists :) Although changing from (un)ordered list to task list still requires to first disable the previous type and then manually select task list
Activity
max-nextcloud commentedon Oct 18, 2022
Switching between bullet and numbered list seems to work fine for me.
"Only" issue seems to be switching between checkbox and the other two list types in either way.
When on a checkbox list the other two list types are greyed out. So looks like tiptap already thinks it cannot do this.
I don't remember how this was fixed after the tiptap2 migration but i remember discussing it at length in a tiptap issue: ueberdosis/tiptap#2428
mejo- commentedon Jun 7, 2023
The problem seems that some commands are reported as not possible by
$editor.can()even though they can be used without problems. E.g. switching from a bullet list to either of ordered list (Ctrl-Shift-7), check list (Ctrl-Shift-9) or blockquote (Ctrl-Shift-B) works well via keyboard shortcuts, even though e.g.$editor.can().toggleOrderedList()returns false, leading to the corresponding menu action being disabled.Related upstream issue: ueberdosis/tiptap#4057
juliusknorr commentedon Aug 29, 2023
I looked a bit into this when checking other list issues:
It seems that this part here is failing to validate that the list items are valid content for the different types bullet and task list for example, as task list uses a different taskitem node type: https://github.com/ueberdosis/tiptap/blob/d6657233e718ee465dbe096c8f40a7910d15e696/packages/core/src/commands/toggleList.ts#L98
We or tiptap either would need to switch to a shared item node type or maybe could rework the command to not only change the list type but also the list item types. Haven't looked further on what would be the best or lowest effort approach.
jospoortvliet commentedon Oct 2, 2025
So it is possible to do it with a shortcut but the menu can't do it? That's very confusing 🥲
It's a bit of a frequent annoyance so I'm going to try to learn the shortcuts then, I'm very happy with the shortcut overview in that regard. Makes it easy.
janbaum commentedon Feb 11, 2026
Just saw this, weeks after creating #8112. I think my issue is kind of a duplicate of this one, so I will comment here, feel free to close #8112 if you agree 👍 Also, I don't fully understand the previous analysis you all did on this issue, so I thought I just describe what I see and you can happily ignore it, if says what you figured out previously 😬
First, switching between all types of lists works, if:
There seems no option to changes list types directly, no matter from which/to which type. As said by you before, shortcuts work fine.
I think this is a rather famous papercut among users, too :)
mejo- commentedon May 7, 2026
Crazy news, but apparently this got fixed 🎉 Most likely it happened with the upgrade to Tiptap v3. I can no longer reproduce this issue in Nextcloud 33 and above.
janbaum commentedon May 28, 2026
Yes, I can now directly change between ordered-, and unordered lists :) Although changing from (un)ordered list to task list still requires to first disable the previous type and then manually select task list
mejo- commentedon May 28, 2026
This will be fixed with the upcoming server releases as well, see #8536