Skip to content

[DUPLICATE — use oss-factory #67] Promotion queue #19

Closed as duplicate

Description

@kvnloo

Single upstream promotion queue — kvnloo/OpenShell

Canonical promotion-readiness thread for kvnloo/OpenShell (origin NVIDIA/OpenShell). Snapshot 2026-10-16. All fork issues, PRs, commits, experiment receipts and human credit remain at their original locations; this issue is the single per-repo promotion queue. The all-factory #14 dashboard indexes queues across repositories. Do not duplicate promotion threads.

Candidates / QA dispositions

QA state Existing carrier Remaining independent gate
CHECK PR #16 third-party extension capability docs Reviewer/required protocol and source docs recheck
HOLD PRs #10/#12/#15 VM/OTEL fixes Maintainer vouch prerequisite; do not bypass origin access
CHECK PR #13 Helm sandbox UID/GID Render validation; maintainer policy/vouch
CHECK PR #1/#4/#7 doctor Podman work Overlap with existing owner PR NVIDIA#3748; do not duplicate
REGISTRY_PENDING Factory project NVIDIA#67 Await registered fork routing; preserve DCO and vouch policy

No new origin write is authorized by this queue. Previous fork statuses are not refreshed exact-head CI: treat them as CHECK unless current origin ownership, requirement, fork SHA, test and policy receipts, review/CI and HITL are independently reverified. Other fork open PRs are UNTRIAGED, not implicitly ready. Do not copy broad experiments or synthetic-speed claims into origin as fixes.

Promotion update rule

For every genuinely upstream-ready unique leaf, append/update a single row with full SHA, existing code/PR/issue links, original author credit, validated supported requirement and impact, exact tests and reviewers, CI + collision results, explicit origin HITL, and next upstream action. Highest priority: live origin maintainer feedback/failing CI, then independently qualified small corrections. If an origin PR already exists, work on that owner thread rather than opening another. On merge record origin link/merge SHA and mark LANDED. If tests/claims fail, record NO-GO and retire; preserve negative evidence. Never create another promotion issue for this repo, merge defaults, force update, bypass approval, spend paid compute or ping humans from this tracking issue.

Registry caveat: this project does not currently have a unique active coordination_repo entry in factory/projects.json; this issue is a human-readable fork queue, not a claim that factory routing/HITL is registered.

Activity

  1. kvnloo commented on Oct 16, 2026

    @kvnloo
    OwnerAuthor

    Duplicate promotion index; superseded by canonical #18. The original evidence and contributor credit on this issue remain available, but promotion updates go to #18. No implementation or origin PR is being closed.

  2. changed the title [-]Promotion queue — upstream candidates (single canonical issue)[/-] [+][DUPLICATE — use oss-factory #67] Promotion queue[/+] on Oct 16, 2026
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions