Skip to content

Survey: where Vocarium could serve, with four experiments and a proposed theorem - #84

Open
hyperpolymath wants to merge 4 commits into
claude/stack-coherence-gatefrom
claude/vocarium-survey
Open

hyperpolymath wants to merge 4 commits into
claude/stack-coherence-gatefrom
claude/vocarium-survey

Conversation

@hyperpolymath

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

Summary

A survey asking whether Vocarium has a use in four other parts of the estate: the Palimpsest licence's logic, the chora identity registry, VeriSimDB's consonance subjects, and the cadastre. Each question is put to the built store engine and the shipped checker. It also compares the two things the estate calls a warrant and proposes a theorem that would join them.

Stacked on #83 (base claude/stack-coherence-gate) so the two changelog entries do not conflict.

It changes no specification, licence, proof or sibling repository. Nothing is adopted.

Changes

  • docs/theory/formalisms/vocarium-survey.adoc: the note.
  • examples/survey/*.jsonl: four fixtures as Vocarium store records.
  • tests/check-survey-experiments.sh (just survey): re-runs the experiments and compares each verdict with the note. It needs VOC and TROPECHECK_BIN; a missing binary fails, it does not skip. It is not wired into CI, because this repository builds neither binary.

Results (run 2026-11-17)

Experiment Result
Palimpsest: non-interpretive ingestion, metadata kept refused under "carries emotional lineage" (fate.context); accepted under "provenance intact"
Palimpsest: metadata stripped refused under both; the second names fate.record
Consent scope consent for research is accepted by a floor asking for consent for training. This is trope-checker#125.
Chora rename resolves by id; refused by old path (fate.bearer)
Cadastre row enough for a triage queue; refused as a description (fate.quality)
Vocarium gap a revocation record is refused ("reserved for M2")
Vocarium gap the IR voc invoke emits carries no warrant id and no node text

For the owner to weigh

  • The note says the stack must not be used to decide consent until #125 is settled.
  • §6 claims Vocarium's warrant and the epistemic-types warrant are one notion at two levels of detail, and states three theorems (W-1 to W-3). None is proved. W-2 is the small one: it should follow from Palimpsest's no-transfer. Proving it belongs to the proof session and its kernels.
  • §7 lists three bridge candidates for Mathesis. They were not written to Mathesis.
  • The note records a disagreement inside Palimpsest about AI training (README, config.ncl, PALIMPSEST.adoc) and takes no side. That is licence content.
  • The fixtures' grades are modelling choices. A different choice gives a different verdict.

Not tested

  • The Idris2 reference checker was not run; only the Rust core.
  • Everything about Palimpsest, chora, VeriSimDB, the cadastre, epistemic-types and Mathesis was read at the commits listed in §8. No tool of theirs was run.
  • AsciiDoc rendering was not checked locally (no asciidoctor here); CI's docs check runs it.

RSR Quality Checklist

Required

  • Tests pass: tests/check-survey-experiments.sh 12 of 12; vocabulary and root-shape checks pass
  • Linter: ShellCheck not run locally; CI runs it
  • No banned language patterns (bash and jq only)
  • SPDX headers on new files
  • No secrets

As Applicable

  • CHANGELOG updated
  • Documentation index updated (docs/theory/README.adoc)

Testing

VOC=…/voc TROPECHECK_BIN=…/tropecheck-rs bash tests/check-survey-experiments.sh
  -> survey experiments: 12 of 12 as recorded

voc was built from vocarium 3ef6286 with Zig 0.16.0. tropecheck-rs was built from trope-checker sources equal to main in src/, schemas/ and spec/.


Generated by Claude Code

…iments

Asks whether Vocarium has a use in four other parts of the estate: the
Palimpsest licence's logic, the chora identity registry, VeriSimDB's
consonance subjects, and the cadastre. Each question is put to the built
store engine and the shipped checker, with fixtures in examples/survey/.
tests/check-survey-experiments.sh re-runs all of it: 12 results.

Run results:
- A non-interpretive ingestion is refused under a use that claims the
  work's context survives, and accepted or refused on provenance according
  to whether the metadata was kept.
- Consent for research satisfies a floor that asks for consent for
  training. This is trope-checker issue 125, in the setting where it
  matters. The note says the stack must not decide consent until it is
  settled.
- A renamed repository identity resolves by id and not by old path.
- A cadastre row is enough to queue a repository and not to describe it.
- Vocarium refuses a revocation record, and the IR it emits carries no
  warrant: two gaps, both measured.

It compares Vocarium's warrant record with the epistemic-types levels
that Palimpsest's proved warrant model uses, and states three theorems
on the level of a verdict. None is proved. It lists three bridge
candidates for Mathesis without writing to it.

Read only: no specification, licence, proof or sibling repository is
changed.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.2 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01J4QvDim4mMEfCer9SiAV4H
@hyperpolymath
hyperpolymath added this pull request to stack #85 November 17, 2026 13:51
@hyperpolymath
hyperpolymath marked this pull request as ready for review November 17, 2026 13:52
@sonarqubecloud

Copy link
Copy Markdown

Repository owner deleted a comment from chatgpt-codex-connector Bot Nov 17, 2026
Repository owner deleted a comment from chatgpt-codex-connector Bot Nov 17, 2026
Repository owner deleted a comment from coderabbitai Bot Nov 17, 2026
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants