Verify fixed temporal premises and typed contacts for PR5713 (no new κ)

docs/ci-verification.md

@@ -3,7 +3,9 @@
 ## Current selected-family replay: #5599
 
 The [selected record](../certificates/selected-result.json) binds conditional
-κ = 0.00310045. `make frontier5599-verify` authenticates the complete source
+κ = 0.00310045 to the [proof review](research/pr-intake-evidence/pr5599-completion/PROOF-REVIEW.md)
+and [explicit source closure](../certificates/frontier5599-source.json).
+`make frontier5599-verify` authenticates the complete source
 closure and claim derivation, then executes primary, independent caller
 positive-control, adapted caller and optimized primary checks serially. The
 Linux [audit run](https://github.com/CrocSwap/integer-mult-bounds/actions/runs/40253906841)

research/p104-temporal-fixed-independent-audit/ADAPTATION.json

@@ -0,0 +1,97 @@
+{
+  "schema": "exact-local-to-portable-core-preservation/v1",
+  "historical_registered_checker_sha256": "e2c42f6f5db304067661ec3d54e6c94ebf7bc2fa82d4c8ded7f714cdcb461aa3",
+  "portable_checker_sha256": "bce6cdf82cb1492d209c241670df894548a485b89622a39851f26352f61e999b",
+  "portable_checker_execution": "QUALIFIED_DIRECT_NORMAL_AND_EXPLICIT_O",
+  "scientific_core_definition": "Exact source bytes of the named constants/classes/functions, including Audit and coefficient/JSON parser helpers",
+  "scientific_core_node_sha256": {
+    "LIMITS": "bcfad909c83eb410476072c9603a9dd09b475a64a5c52f7c12f77ee511d80710",
+    "BOUNDS": "5d57aa29f09f22d8f20fdb0d9f1fb7b5c0e3db209d24a337fdbed726d9980039",
+    "SUBJECT": "e03093b733eb5aea089cd2c0539c93c6be995c877e27ae949857d083a8eada73",
+    "REQUIRED": "ef1bbcee82770d60886fd7afaef5447e34b3b70996565aa67b6830b9f499e6f2",
+    "OPTIONAL": "04a77362c62652828182c249b89993fce620827e18a813a15d5960f4354cb709",
+    "ARITY": "a6456e1cce32a4d8382c0dfaa52be889c7d2cf029b097cb2d0145e59700eb971",
+    "Unresolved": "63f794cb96bb4a058687543f49f1d50e9d6daf19eff16da580be86679ca09ea6",
+    "Falsified": "9cd780b5a3be594f0be172e08634d9fc50114ad32aec494fbee170d535122ab6",
+    "Incomplete": "7043898ab5f5bf04fed7a5e2750313b15e13939d6e173ceb90dba85e306ce350",
+    "need": "97df2cebe9713e585cee46378f33de80ff329ee94ec4e3b1e77f6e86230f2285",
+    "fixed": "4ddbcfdf99302de9b8daeef4abc615b810d1ce8c6ad4c52523eb17977abc3a4b",
+    "deadline": "732e0fdd5efa3e2b5bfb58b8f1a48127fe6b8d4b9873680b2c694080d47ebec5",
+    "integer": "8fa81b024aa379054abee9fd13dfff378c259b53707d25bec1faa058d251699d",
+    "canonical": "223f52f64a8c81054b8d5b33d27c7a9ab7819039b9e8b10ca3120bd39d06a8ca",
+    "sha": "2f1541faf4c4ebe2f74c17d4b666982327a0f1e144708a531c92f08669705d57",
+    "bounded_read": "674a57f3d7df19d24af518fb218e98d1905200eb39d2b6d72d5dacdba5be60da",
+    "preflight": "cb296c8a20adcbb887ffd552a14303d5cf867965a3fdc88dcc4e431422d27bb9",
+    "unique_pairs": "9622d3e0f3c2d2a29295a9f86276d2c54612945736ace45131c447132b601aeb",
+    "reject_number": "9d23ed500af8c95662864cacbfd92c9c70e25a89bd03a62d848d4098b0065cba",
+    "decode": "4e3b649c43b401f906ed3724dcb53da4213fbdb5595217171da62c693762c425",
+    "coefficient": "1215015eeb9b01adccb8c81044b97ee4c378a0a9e6846fcd5c7b91a4ea19a39d",
+    "Audit": "c49d10a692198ffeb18b67079db5743fc33a5a775f447ed8e39f969b3ed43162"
+  },
+  "scientific_core_manifest_sha256": "6c2de9fa2d5714e7501c308d06492e5bf251c6e9bd341efff0e4f6629c0d2974",
+  "all_named_nodes_byte_identical": true,
+  "private_exact_diff_sha256": "4b01e71fad5593ae1bedbbb5a7e2f55325d86a8c51ce96322f5289499d0fe712",
+  "private_diff_not_public_payload": true,
+  "wrapper_changes": [
+    "One explicit data-file path replaces workspace-specific source path and private review/registration/acquisition wrapper",
+    "Pinned LICENSE/NOTICE companions verified as data; immutable WORD hash/blob/length checks remain before decode",
+    "Only basename/public source pins and current code hash enter new output; private I/O paths are omitted",
+    "Unexpected exception messages suppress local paths; scientific statuses/causal predicates/typed trajectory unchanged"
+  ],
+  "historical_receipt_does_not_validate_portable_wrapper": true,
+  "root_qualification_request": "The completed private V2 request/registration are retained outside this public package; this evidence revision grants no further run.",
+  "historical_full_scientific_projection": {
+    "excluded_top_level_fields": [
+      "binding",
+      "elapsed_seconds_internal",
+      "runtime_memory_and_termination_evidence",
+      "source"
+    ],
+    "exclusion_reason": "Private source/binding wrapper and explicit runtime/elapsed fields only; public immutable source pins are retained separately.",
+    "included_top_level_fields": [
+      "340_stronger_provenance_observation",
+      "747_read_lifetimes",
+      "anchors",
+      "assumptions",
+      "coverage",
+      "credited_causal_identity",
+      "cuts",
+      "decoded_word_sha256_recorded_after_authorized_decode",
+      "ledgers",
+      "new_kappa",
+      "no_fallback",
+      "not_proved",
+      "object_id",
+      "predicates",
+      "source_head",
+      "status",
+      "write_census"
+    ],
+    "sha256": "8ad201fe2ce3ebcbb0a081774790fd4511d3ecce1b5b5c1cee3dd9bde033895c",
+    "exact_equality_to_distributed_scientific_data": true,
+    "historical_stdout_sha256": "ef45148b8ee100c237432d730c6384e74f436c4e99ccf0195dbd177af50cb02e"
+  },
+  "v2_controls": {
+    "status": "QUALIFIED_ALL_12_EXPLICIT_SYNTHETIC_CONTROLS",
+    "portable_verify_unchanged_from_v1": true,
+    "controls_sha256": "9e9e14f995b47afb13d48a21cdd4c68750ef121a91b00298dd1e5de7a9df697c",
+    "fixtures_sha256": "494736481a4722b76ca94584df74fec1f58d54d62abe86a4b11ec89da5421c5b",
+    "raw_verifier_compile_instead_of_pyc_import": true,
+    "original_authenticated_before_in_memory_derivatives": true,
+    "assert_acceptance_used": false,
+    "normal_or_control_phase_executed": true
+  },
+  "qualification": {
+    "status": "PASS_THREE_PHASE_PORTABLE_FIXED_AUDIT_QUALIFICATION_ONLY",
+    "outcome_sha256": "7298b86c76e400876962c3daf8908a09694bee05501b8b0f62d2fd17d91c8fc8",
+    "postrun_review_sha256": "5162081de87c51ebb8dc3a8375513928ad1fb39226c60e7f9dfed78a4477f1ce",
+    "root_acceptance_metadata_sha256": "84d22f2e8f7c5bd3621064793de1dea4ce9a2363d8f1e7aad7a192cec4580666",
+    "normal_and_explicit_O_passed": true,
+    "synthetic_controls_passed": 12,
+    "full_scientific_projection_sha256": "8ad201fe2ce3ebcbb0a081774790fd4511d3ecce1b5b5c1cee3dd9bde033895c",
+    "generic_metadata_validation": "NOT_RUN",
+    "export": "NOT_RUN",
+    "hosted_replay": "NOT_RUN"
+  },
+  "postrun_revision": "Documentation/evidence/metadata only. verify.py, controls.py, fixtures, scientific-core nodes, historical reference and all retained input pins are unchanged."
+}

research/p104-temporal-fixed-independent-audit/ADAPTATION.md

@@ -0,0 +1,17 @@
+# Exact adaptation and postrun boundary
+
+Historical local checker SHA256: `e2c42f6f5db304067661ec3d54e6c94ebf7bc2fa82d4c8ded7f714cdcb461aa3`.
+
+Qualified portable verifier: `bce6cdf82cb1492d209c241670df894548a485b89622a39851f26352f61e999b`.
+
+Qualified controls: `9e9e14f995b47afb13d48a21cdd4c68750ef121a91b00298dd1e5de7a9df697c`; fixtures: `494736481a4722b76ca94584df74fec1f58d54d62abe86a4b11ec89da5421c5b`.
+
+The named scientific constants/classes/functions in ADAPTATION.json, including Audit and the input/coefficient parser, retain their exact source bytes from the local checker. Their scientific-core manifest hash is `6c2de9fa2d5714e7501c308d06492e5bf251c6e9bd341efff0e4f6629c0d2974`. The local-to-portable wrapper replaced workspace-specific custody/registration paths with one explicit data argument and active WORD/LICENSE/NOTICE authentication, and removed private paths from output. Its exact private diff was sealed; the private removed lines are not distributed publicly.
+
+V2 added a separate control harness without changing that verifier. It authenticates and compiles raw verifier bytes, avoiding cached verifier bytecode; authenticates the original before in-memory derivatives; compares the full scientific projection; and requires exact intended predicates/sites. All 12 controls have now passed their registered phase. The prospective-only fixture has original 715/747 in 598 and prospective 715 in 3. The coefficient-only 11202 positive fixture is distinct from the unmodified historical-projection comparison. The minimal 340 fixture tests its precise later stability boundary. No assert-only acceptance or source-file mutation is used.
+
+Normal and explicit `-O` direct runs reproduce all 17 historical scientific fields, SHA256 `8ad201fe2ce3ebcbb0a081774790fd4511d3ecce1b5b5c1cee3dd9bde033895c`. Agreement is reproduction, not a new independent checking method. Root's recorded outcome and separate static AI postrun review support only the fixed causal/typed scope; that reviewer did not execute a further replay or reread WORD.
+
+This final-publication revision changes documentation, evidence and metadata only. The verifier, controls, fixtures, historical reference, scientific core and retained input pins remain byte-for-byte unchanged from qualified V2. Frozen preparation-time UNRUN notices in hash-bound code/fixtures are retained as historical input labels; current execution evidence is stored separately. V1 and V2 local artifacts remain preserved. No new scientific run, source decode, export, Git or upstream action occurred during this revision.
+
+The implementation/publication identity and final byte/history/generic/CI/render checks remain root-owned and pending. Generic/export/hosted passes are not inferred from direct qualification. No new kappa or broader native/caller/price admission follows.

research/p104-temporal-fixed-independent-audit/CONTROL-CONTRACTS.json

@@ -0,0 +1,73 @@
+{
+  "schema": "portable-fixed5713-control-contracts/v2",
+  "status": "QUALIFIED_12_EXPLICIT_SYNTHETIC_BOUNDARY_CONTROLS",
+  "harness_implemented": true,
+  "automatic_execution_authorized": false,
+  "immutable_source_rule": "Never modify the original retained WORD. A future separately reviewed harness may authenticate it and construct explicitly synthetic in-memory derivatives with unique synthetic labels; no derivative is source evidence.",
+  "default_pinned_wrapper": "Every changed compressed input fails custody before decode. Semantic controls therefore require an explicitly labeled synthetic Audit-level harness, not a bypass presented as original data.",
+  "designs": [
+    {
+      "id": "SOURCE_BYTES",
+      "operation": "Change one compressed byte in an isolated synthetic copy named WORD.json.gz",
+      "expected": "BINDING_UNRESOLVED before gzip/JSON decoding",
+      "exercises": "Custody fail-closed path"
+    },
+    {
+      "id": "HIDDEN715_READ",
+      "operation": "Synthetic replacement of original event823 by ADD207,715,1@3; label derivative and retain original unchanged",
+      "expected": "FIXED_SUFFICIENT_PREMISE_NOT_ESTABLISHED:715_NO_OUTWARD_OBSERVER_OR_FORBIDDEN_CHANGE at823",
+      "exercises": "Causal source-observer gate, not an identity counterexample"
+    },
+    {
+      "id": "CHANGED747_WRITE",
+      "operation": "Synthetic replacement of known source-read13574 by ADD747,713,1@598",
+      "expected": "Fixed747 sufficient continuity premise not established at13574",
+      "exercises": "Known active owned destination write, without claiming actual nonzero defect"
+    },
+    {
+      "id": "CHANGED747_LIFETIME",
+      "operation": "Synthetic replacement of13574 by CLEAR747@598",
+      "expected": "Fixed747 continuity/lifecycle premise not established at13574",
+      "exercises": "Owned lifetime continuity; no original source mutated"
+    },
+    {
+      "id": "RETAINED715_WRONG_FRAME",
+      "operation": "Synthetic replacement of nonanchor13579 (original CLEAR747@598) by ADD715,747,1@598; old715/747 are598, prospective715 is3.",
+      "expected": "PROSPECTIVE715_RETAINED_SCALAR_CONTACT at13579; original tracked common frame passes.",
+      "exercises": "Destination-only ADD passes the causal barrier and original typing but fails prospective typing. Synthetic branch test only; no actual source mutation/result."
+    },
+    {
+      "id": "UNKNOWN_SEMANTICS",
+      "operation": "Synthetic replacement at823 by an unknown QUERY event",
+      "expected": "BINDING_UNRESOLVED, never a scientific falsifier",
+      "exercises": "Closed grammar/observer ambiguity"
+    }
+  ],
+  "qualification": {
+    "status": "PASS_THREE_PHASE_PORTABLE_FIXED_AUDIT_QUALIFICATION_ONLY",
+    "outcome_sha256": "7298b86c76e400876962c3daf8908a09694bee05501b8b0f62d2fd17d91c8fc8",
+    "postrun_review_sha256": "5162081de87c51ebb8dc3a8375513928ad1fb39226c60e7f9dfed78a4477f1ce",
+    "root_acceptance_metadata_sha256": "84d22f2e8f7c5bd3621064793de1dea4ce9a2363d8f1e7aad7a192cec4580666",
+    "normal_and_explicit_O_passed": true,
+    "synthetic_controls_passed": 12,
+    "full_scientific_projection_sha256": "8ad201fe2ce3ebcbb0a081774790fd4511d3ecce1b5b5c1cee3dd9bde033895c",
+    "generic_metadata_validation": "NOT_RUN",
+    "export": "NOT_RUN",
+    "hosted_replay": "NOT_RUN"
+  },
+  "harness": "controls.py authenticates raw portable verifier and compiles the authenticated bytes; no stale verify.pyc or author import.",
+  "fixtures": "CONTROL-FIXTURES.json; fixed SHA256 bound by controls.py",
+  "original_authentication": "Actual normal wrapper baseline authenticates all original inputs and compares complete scientific projection before any derivative; source bytes are authenticated again for byte-mismatch test.",
+  "acceptance": "Explicit require/exception checks, no assert-only acceptance. Exact intended predicate/site required for every negative semantic fixture.",
+  "synthetic_label": "Every emitted test record is SYNTHETIC_CONTROL_ONLY, including envelope probes and original-baseline reference inside the harness.",
+  "other_implemented_checks": [
+    "Original normal status/envelope/body hash and complete historical scientific projection",
+    "Corrupted receipt digest rejected",
+    "Unscoped PASS status rejected even with a matching digest",
+    "Missing cuts rejected even with a matching digest",
+    "Coefficient-only11202 write remains nonblocking",
+    "Required minimal340 interval write rejected at its exact intended predicate"
+  ],
+  "execution": "One registered synthetic-control phase completed all12 cases with exact intended outcomes and labels. No actual source counterexample is proved, and no automatic rerun/export or source repair is authorized.",
+  "frozen_fixture_status_note": "CONTROL-FIXTURES.json and source headers retain preparation-time UNRUN notices to preserve qualified hashes. Their execution status is recorded separately here and in qualification evidence."
+}

research/p104-temporal-fixed-independent-audit/CONTROL-FIXTURES.json

@@ -0,0 +1,159 @@
+{
+  "schema": "portable5713-explicit-synthetic-control-fixtures/v2",
+  "label": "SYNTHETIC_CONTROL_ONLY",
+  "status": "IMPLEMENTED_UNRUN",
+  "original_file_mutation": false,
+  "verifier_sha256": "bce6cdf82cb1492d209c241670df894548a485b89622a39851f26352f61e999b",
+  "event_mutants": [
+    {
+      "id": "HIDDEN715_READ",
+      "index": 823,
+      "original_expected": [
+        "ADD",
+        207,
+        720,
+        "-2",
+        3
+      ],
+      "replacement": [
+        "ADD",
+        207,
+        715,
+        "1",
+        3
+      ],
+      "expected_kind": "fixed_premise",
+      "expected_predicate": "715_NO_OUTWARD_OBSERVER_OR_FORBIDDEN_CHANGE",
+      "prerequisite": "CUT823_715_FRAME3"
+    },
+    {
+      "id": "CHANGED747_VALUE_WRITE",
+      "index": 13574,
+      "original_expected": [
+        "ADD",
+        713,
+        747,
+        "1",
+        598
+      ],
+      "replacement": [
+        "ADD",
+        747,
+        713,
+        "1",
+        598
+      ],
+      "expected_kind": "fixed_premise",
+      "expected_predicate": "747_NO_INTERVENING_WRITE_OR_LIFECYCLE",
+      "prerequisite": "747_LIVE_598"
+    },
+    {
+      "id": "CHANGED747_LIFETIME",
+      "index": 13574,
+      "original_expected": [
+        "ADD",
+        713,
+        747,
+        "1",
+        598
+      ],
+      "replacement": [
+        "CLEAR",
+        747,
+        598
+      ],
+      "expected_kind": "fixed_premise",
+      "expected_predicate": "747_NO_INTERVENING_WRITE_OR_LIFECYCLE",
+      "prerequisite": "747_LIVE_598"
+    },
+    {
+      "id": "PROSPECTIVE_ONLY_715_CONTACT",
+      "index": 13579,
+      "original_expected": [
+        "CLEAR",
+        747,
+        598
+      ],
+      "replacement": [
+        "ADD",
+        715,
+        747,
+        "1",
+        598
+      ],
+      "expected_kind": "fixed_premise",
+      "expected_predicate": "PROSPECTIVE715_RETAINED_SCALAR_CONTACT",
+      "expected_frame": 598,
+      "expected_actual": 3,
+      "prerequisite": "715_AND747_LIVE_598_AFTER13578"
+    },
+    {
+      "id": "UNKNOWN_SEMANTICS",
+      "index": 823,
+      "original_expected": [
+        "ADD",
+        207,
+        720,
+        "-2",
+        3
+      ],
+      "replacement": [
+        "QUERY",
+        715
+      ],
+      "expected_kind": "unresolved",
+      "expected_reason": "Unknown opcode/arity",
+      "prerequisite": "CUT823_715_FRAME3"
+    },
+    {
+      "id": "NONBLOCKING11202_WRITE",
+      "index": 11202,
+      "original_expected": [
+        "ADD",
+        340,
+        337,
+        "1",
+        396
+      ],
+      "replacement": [
+        "ADD",
+        340,
+        337,
+        "2",
+        396
+      ],
+      "expected_kind": "pass",
+      "prerequisite": "340_FRAME396_AT11202"
+    },
+    {
+      "id": "MINIMAL340_INTERVAL_WRITE",
+      "index": 14655,
+      "original_expected": [
+        "MOVE",
+        712,
+        598,
+        397,
+        false
+      ],
+      "replacement": [
+        "ADD",
+        340,
+        525,
+        "1",
+        396
+      ],
+      "expected_kind": "fixed_premise",
+      "expected_predicate": "340_MINIMAL_READ_TO_CUT_STABILITY",
+      "prerequisite": "340_AND525_FRAME396_AFTER14654"
+    }
+  ],
+  "other_controls": [
+    "ORIGINAL_BASELINE_ENVELOPE_AND_FULL_PROJECTION",
+    "SOURCE_BYTE_MISMATCH_PREDECODE",
+    "BAD_ENVELOPE_HASH",
+    "UNSCOPED_PASS_STATUS",
+    "MISSING_SCIENTIFIC_PROJECTION_FIELD"
+  ],
+  "meaning": "Every derivative is synthetic. A rejected sufficient premise is not an identity counterexample or author defect. No fixture is source evidence.",
+  "execution": "Future separately registered controls only; no automatic invocation, retries, source writes or unregistered grant."
+}