Skip to content

Independently verify the P104 forward caller and target bindings (no new κ) - #5550

Merged
Mister-Meeseeks merged 1 commit into
CrocSwap:mainfrom
Clear1nsight:p104-caller-independent-20261025
Oct 25, 2026
Merged

Mister-Meeseeks merged 1 commit into
CrocSwap:mainfrom
Clear1nsight:p104-caller-independent-20261025

Conversation

@Clear1nsight

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Change and mathematical scope

Publishes an independent, source-bound audit of the 265-axis forward P104 caller and its productive target bindings in PR #5545. This closes one finite validation layer under retained premises. No new construction, paid-profile change, κ gain, global ceiling or full parent admission is claimed.

The checker covers 7,488 actual entry/exit contacts and their composed local block coefficients, the complete 32-bank free-Laurent caller, 3,328 main input/output canonicalizers and final corrections, 527 native helper normalizers, 208 intrinsic main adapters, and 9,486 fresh helper identities. It emits all 3,120 whole-idle jobs and 1,560 corrected positive-child query recipes. The complete invoice is unchanged: 69,912 paid jobs and 12,814 independent productive fields.

The proof/accounting argument binds actual route phases and target input aliases. It keeps scalar signs outside digit-column tensor powers and excludes scratch and spectators from productive credit. Signed-Pauli equality plus an independently executed exact dense phase anchor checks the native target maps. Source compiler and literal circuit definitions are credited reuse.

The separate 127,292,680 ordinary figure is an abstract address/phase/scalar pass bound under retained per-pass/tape costs, below the source allowance 184,647,552. It is not newly funded machine work, a precision theorem, recursive rank credit or a κ reserve.

The all-input/all-width local native ABI and untouched paid-map correctness remain inherited. Owned query cleanup is checked against the fixed template; the erasure framework is not independently proved. Contact inverses are not a complete-caller raw inverse transpose. Full raw dual, uniform precision/tape/storage, compiler reserve, complete outer conjunction and human/formal acceptance remain open. Five framework assumptions remain. See review limits.

Task and overlap

Task scalar-to-moment, priority revision 7, changed scope / partial, from the explicit user assignment to validate this pending caller. The card's positive paid-profile gain gate is not claimed met. TASK.json preserves the original card and states the actual scope.

Publication: 6125c07ae8ba4b8550e2a0a28a2c6be503153059, directly based on canonical 32890bc5de034ab8fc93ac88ead7279a6a416d04. Reviewed PR #5545: 18968423711fd902aaee1099979497d55603e1dc; predecessor #5544: e2a6cce2f9db5a2c5f9714f4b9e5292dd3a10581. The source author released scope and requested independent review. Current main guidance, relevant source/PR discussion and bounded changed-PR checks were refreshed. No competing successor appeared in that coverage; hidden/unpublished work is not covered exhaustively.

Our PR #5548, head b038f9d9b5cf0ce92184da909e57a3be476fc812, covers the earlier local contact/native replacement and scoped repeated-H5 ceiling. This PR adds the forward caller/target layer. It reuses only the dense interpreter needed here and authenticates previous receipts without rerunning those older audits. The predecessor construction and packages are unchanged.

The source-bound capsule retains the exact successful checker, complete expected output and authenticated inputs. Pending source bytes are included for offline replay; no pending Git object or network is required at runtime. Canonical compiler, circuit and phase sources remain declared live inputs. Source-history checks authenticate those registered pins, not merger or acceptance of the pending construction.

Validation

Python 3.12.3, standard library:

python3 -B scripts/research_package.py --package research/p104-caller-independent-audit --check-only
python3 -B scripts/research_package.py --package research/p104-caller-independent-audit
python3 -B scripts/check_research_commit.py --package research/p104-caller-independent-audit --check-source-history

Expected marker: PASS_P104_FORWARD_CALLER_INDEPENDENT_AUDIT.

  • Metadata/pins and exact published-commit/source-history checks passed for all 38 package/input files. Remote tree equals the checked local tree; canonical main is the direct parent.
  • Original normal/optimized pair passed under the unchanged shared guard in 100.917 s / 82.35 MiB, within 150 s / 512 MiB. Every 5,990,419 scientific output bytes matches, zero scientific exclusions. SHA256: b51a7d19c10faea7d569a48e9536db8ba1e7418f8dd8dfb25646cc87cc9c4009.
  • The registered portable normal/optimized replay passed in 103.299 s / 123.77 MiB under the same outer cap, comparing every byte with the frozen original output.
  • A relocated read-only, Git-free optimized export with spaces in its path and empty PATH passed in 47.173 s / 90.91 MiB. All 39 exported files remained unchanged.
  • Ten scoped controls reject wrong route, omitted contact translation, nonzero absolute phase, exterior sign error, lost idle, helper alias collision, missing final translation, scratch/source collision, missing inverse-Q correction and packed-exponent overflow. Negative-power cancellation also passes. Control scope is explicit; not every control is a full mutated-source replay.
  • Separate on-disk canonical-source and expected-receipt corruptions fail before the scientific worker. An injected source exception was not imported. A fresh private bytecode namespace also isolates the scientific subprocess.

The first checker exceeded 512 MiB before a result; its frozen code and closeout are retained as history. The successful revision bounds the phase cache, packs all 34 exact exponents with overflow rejection, and streams output. It retains all 265 axes and full matrix coverage; no floating or finite-order shortcut is used. Original operational stage traces are separate from scientific output. Mode equality is reproducibility, not independent human review. Hosted CI for this PR is separate from these completed local receipts and from #5548's hosted success.

Credit

Ali Romman (#5544/#5545); Gareth Davidson (#2305), David Arias (#2152), Cinna Davis (#2219/controller); Jacob Alan Sussman, zxv, Cao Yifan and retained native, Clifford, geometry, tensor, compiler and analytic authors. Original source notices remain intact.

New independent checker, memory-bounded representation, source custody and publication for Chris R/Clear1nsight with substantial OpenAI Codex assistance. Apache-2.0. No independent human or proof-kernel acceptance claimed.

Open next questions

The structured questions and seven-field handoff specify relevance, first steps and blockers.

  1. Review target input aliases and the ordinary-cost premises, then choose one missing native/complete-caller-dual obligation. The actual raw inverse transpose and untouched paid native foundation matter before invoking parent funding.
  2. Bind precision/tape/storage, erasure and retained compiler/outer reserves to this fixed complete caller. The abstract pass census is not that conjunction.
  3. For κ≥.0033, nominate one broader paid-path mechanism with complete optimistic costs and a small physical falsifier. This unchanged invoice does not lift Independently verify P104 contact phases and bound repeated H5 retiming (no new κ) #5548's repeated-H5 raw ceiling (.003106074473,.003106074474).

This completed layer stops after publication. No new construction scan, recurring worker, merge or selected change is authorized by the submission.

@Clear1nsight

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

HANDOFF — public P104 forward caller and target-binding validation (no new κ)

Research discussion / PR / artifact: This PR and the complete package are canonical. This publishes the previously local caller layer supporting #5545; #5548 remains the separate preceding contact/native/ceiling contribution.

Exact commit: Publication 6125c07ae8ba4b8550e2a0a28a2c6be503153059, directly based on canonical 32890bc5de034ab8fc93ac88ead7279a6a416d04. Reviewed #5545 18968423711fd902aaee1099979497d55603e1dc; predecessor #5544 e2a6cce2f9db5a2c5f9714f4b9e5292dd3a10581. Exact source/compiler/circuit/phase inputs, successful checker, full expected output and original receipts are authenticated. No pending Git object or network is required at runtime.

What is established: 7,488 actual265-axis contact phases and composed local coefficients; complete32-bank free-Laurent endpoint;3,328 main input/output aliases and final corrections;527 native helper normalizers and208 main adapters;9,486 fresh helper identities without double credit;3,120 whole-idle jobs and1,560 corrected positive-child query recipes. Complete invoice remains69,912 paid jobs and12,814 productive fields. The separate127,292,680 ordinary figure is an abstract pass bound under retained costs, not a new precision theorem or recursive budget. The previous repeated-H5 ceiling is unchanged; no κ improvement.

What remains uncertain: Untouched native paid maps and all-input/all-width foundation, actual complete-caller raw inverse transpose required by the compiler, owned-erasure framework, uniform precision/tape/storage, compiler reserve and complete outer conjunction. Contact inverses do not certify the whole-caller dual. Five framework assumptions remain; no independent human/formal acceptance or full parent admission.

Smallest useful next task: Review target input aliases and ordinary-cost applicability, then select one missing native/dual admission obligation against this exact source with actual phases, restoration and costs. A broader.0033 construction requires a distinct complete optimistic bill and smallest physical falsifier; this unchanged profile does not lift the scoped repeated-H5 ceiling. This layer is completed and stopped; no further construction scope is reserved.

Reproduction command and expected runtime: Python3.12/stdlib: python3 -B scripts/research_package.py --package research/p104-caller-independent-audit. Expected marker PASS_P104_FORWARD_CALLER_INDEPENDENT_AUDIT. Original normal/-O pair100.917s/82.35MiB; registered portable pair103.299s/123.77MiB, within150s/512MiB. Every5,990,419 scientific bytes equals the original frozen output, zero scientific exclusions, SHA256 b51a7d19c10faea7d569a48e9536db8ba1e7418f8dd8dfb25646cc87cc9c4009. Read-only Git-free optimized export with empty PATH passed47.173s/90.91MiB, all39 files unchanged. Canonical-source/expected-receipt corruptions reject before science. Exact published-commit/source-history preflight passed38 files. The earlier memory failure remains visible. Mode equality is reproducibility; hosted CI is separate.

Predecessor credit: Ali Romman/#5544/#5545; Gareth Davidson/#2305, David Arias/#2152, Cinna Davis/#2219/controller; Jacob Alan Sussman, zxv, Cao Yifan and retained native/Clifford/geometry/tensor/compiler/analytic authors. New independent checker and publication for Chris R/Clear1nsight with substantial OpenAI Codex assistance; Apache-2.0.

{
  "schema": "integer-mult-coordination/v1",
  "kind": "HANDOFF",
  "task": "scalar-to-moment",
  "scope": "Published P104 forward caller/target verification; unchanged invoice, no new kappa; remaining native/dual/precision/funding admission explicit",
  "base": "32890bc5de034ab8fc93ac88ead7279a6a416d04",
  "expiry": null,
  "artifact": "https://github.com/CrocSwap/integer-mult-bounds/pull/5550"
}

@Clear1nsight

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

Next-stage applicability note: The retained PR5544 proof, section 3 already supplies the sixteen backward main interfaces with ordinary wrappers around forward calls. It explicitly avoids instruction-level transposition of COPY/CLEAR. That is credited source work, and the fixed forward chronology is covered here.

This audit makes no complete-caller raw inverse-transpose claim. Its absence should not automatically be turned into a new prerequisite for this all-forward assembly: first identify the actual downstream compiler/consumer requirement. The proposed next review is the exact uncovered native paid-map inventory, reusing #5548 and this package's coverage, followed by one bounded qualification if justified. Precision/tape and full funding applicability remain separate. No additional experiment or construction scope has started.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants