feat(observation): add domain-separated v3 successor schema representation

[seonghobae]

Current authority — 2026-09-13

This remains the Draft representation-v3 parent slice stacked on Source Observation #6.

• Exact source head: 6b2a8f555725dc79f60432afbc492d6005290a4a.
• Exact stacked base: feat(observation): define immutable PostgreSQL schema snapshot contract #6 287165d399c5f54d6c4b4aa3c15497b47de8244b.
• Current child authority: feat(observation): add v3 relation-scoped index evidence #46 exact cc6c4af9342384e60004430649725a3d220461a4.
• State: OPEN / Draft. Mechanical mergeability is not acceptance evidence.

Keep this parent source unchanged. Do not duplicate, partially cherry-pick, or independently reimplement child repairs. #46 retains the complete ordinary-forward PostgreSQL 18 representation lineage, including exclusion-operator provenance, PERIOD referenced-key completeness, temporal backing-index/lifecycle coherence, retained fixture repairs, column-collation evidence, column-identity declaration/nullability consistency, column-generation declaration mode, column default/generated-expression identity, and first-class PostgreSQL 18 NOT NULL constraint evidence.

The child NOT NULL slice remains NOT_NULL_CONSTRAINT_SOURCE_REPAIRED / ACCEPTANCE_PENDING. In addition to aggregate admission and ordering protection, exact-source review 5190362750 found that pg_constraint.coninhcount is PostgreSQL signed int2 while the public source model previously accepted the full u16 range. RED 2891675822b13282ab57d968cda985d0628920ac, repair 385bf43794849836ef6871c2abad64c124ddd723, doctoring 1b16ce65d674836e88073ba2ea857aa27fb1b2a5, and baseline cc6c4af9342384e60004430649725a3d220461a4 now reject impossible values above 32767 before governed hashing. #46 is not native/hosted GREEN yet.

Central workflow settlement is a separate owner path. .github#2079@20972a57ce768751dbb4b29e7dbed76271bfed14 remains OPEN/Draft/mergeable on protected .github/main@64f483db9d052322c65bcdf1675d66138156f306 with its finding↔confirmed-probe relation still an intentional owner RED; central evidence never transfers here.

Only after one unchanged #46 head reaches terminal native/hosted GREEN should its complete delta be adopted ordinary/non-force into this parent. Then obtain fresh #45 acceptance before #6 propagation. No force-push, destructive rebase, Ready/Draft trigger manipulation, no-op/manual evidence manufacturing, self-approval, review dismissal, synthetic status, or gate weakening.

[coderabbitai]

Important

Review skipped

Auto reviews are disabled on base/target branches other than the default branch.

Please check the settings in the CodeRabbit UI or the .coderabbit.yaml file in this repository. To trigger a single review, invoke the @coderabbitai review command.

⚙️ Run configuration

Configuration used: Organization UI

Review profile: CHILL

Plan: Advanced

Run ID: 3dd6f996-89a1-4c57-8cd3-c82b9c140755

You can disable this status message by setting the reviews.review_status to false in the CodeRabbit configuration file.

Use the checkbox below for a quick retry:

• 🔍 Trigger review

---

Thanks for using CodeRabbit! It's free for OSS, and your support helps us grow. If you like it, consider giving us a shout-out.

❤️ Share

• X
• Mastodon
• Reddit
• LinkedIn

_{Comment @coderabbitai help to get the list of available commands.}

[chatgpt-codex-connector]

You have reached your Codex usage limits for code reviews. You can see your limits in the Codex usage dashboard.
To continue using code reviews, add credits to your account and enable them for code reviews in your settings.

[seonghobae]

현재 exact head 6b2a8f555725dc79f60432afbc492d6005290a4a에서 두 건을 repair finding으로 유지합니다.

1. P0 — #6이 요구한 first-class index evidence가 successor representation에 없습니다. #6의 현재 P0 계약은 index key vs INCLUDE attributes, expression positions, partial predicates, NULL uniqueness, readiness/validity/liveness와 exact receipt coordinate를 보존하도록 요구합니다. 그러나 이 head의 PostgresSchemaSnapshotV3는 relations/domains/enums만 소유하고, SchemaObjectLocationKind도 Table/Column/Constraint/Domain/Enum만 있으며, digest와 every_v3_evidence_kind_has_a_verified_receipt_coordinate test에도 index가 없습니다. 따라서 이 PR을 #6 P0 전체 구현으로 간주하면 안 됩니다. 기존 delta는 보존하고 IndexObservation(또는 동등한 first-class VO), index-specific identity/coordinate/receipt/digest framing 및 각 material index fact의 RED→GREEN을 추가해야 합니다.

2. P1 — DomainObservation.base_type은 exact qualified binding이라고 주장하지만 실제 resolution validation을 거치지 않습니다. canonicalize_snapshot_objects는 relation column의 type_binding만 pg_catalog 또는 observed domain/enum에 resolve되는지 검사하고, 각 domain의 base_type은 검사하지 않습니다. 따라서 allowed schema 안의 domain이 public.missing_type 같은 미관측 qualified base type을 가리켜도 snapshot/digest 생성이 가능합니다. 먼저 DomainObservation::new("public", "event_status_kind", QualifiedTypeName::new("public", "missing_type")?) + no matching domain/enum인 snapshot이 UnknownTypeBinding으로 실패해야 한다는 executable RED를 추가하십시오. 이후 한 개의 exact qualified-type resolver/invariant를 column binding과 domain base binding에 함께 적용해 search_path 추론 없이 fail closed하도록 수리하는 것이 최소 causal fix입니다.

또한 PR body는 Draft, matching the stacked base라고 적혀 있지만 GitHub lifecycle은 현재 non-Draft입니다. Parent #6이 Draft이고 위 P0/P1이 남아 있으므로 lifecycle도 Draft로 되돌리는 것이 맞습니다. 기존 local Rust 1.98 결과는 이 exact source에 대한 유용한 evidence이지만, 위 source repair 이후 새 exact head에서 다시 실행되어야 하며 predecessor GREEN을 승계하면 안 됩니다.

[seonghobae]

추가 DDD/coordinate invariant finding입니다.

P1 — RelationObservation의 UL과 SchemaObjectLocation의 UL이 어긋나고, 현재 Table receipt가 non-table relation에도 발급됩니다. RelationObservation은 View, MaterializedView, Sequence, CompositeType까지 표현하지만 successor location은 여전히 SchemaObjectLocationKind::Table / SchemaObjectElement::Table / /schemas/{schema}/tables/{name}뿐입니다. 더 직접적으로 PostgresSchemaSnapshotV3::contains_location()의 Table branch는 relation name만 비교하고 RelationKind를 확인하지 않으므로, 예를 들어 audit_view()에 대해 SchemaObjectLocation::table("audit", "event_record")를 요청하면 table receipt가 성공합니다.

이 상태에서는 digest 안의 relation kind와 외부 provenance coordinate의 ubiquitous language가 서로 다른 truth를 말합니다. 두 방향 중 하나를 명시적으로 선택해 RED→repair 하십시오. (a) v3에서 generic Relation coordinate(/relations/…)와 필요하면 relation-child column/constraint coordinate를 도입하여 모든 relkind에 정확한 UL을 쓰거나, (b) Table coordinate를 실제 table-family에만 제한하고 view/materialized-view/sequence/composite-type용 versioned coordinate를 별도로 둡니다. 어느 쪽이든 frozen v2 /tables/… meaning은 변경하지 않아야 합니다.

RED에는 최소한 view/sequence snapshot이 Table kind receipt로 오인되지 않는 case와, 선택한 successor coordinate가 relation kind를 loss 없이 식별하는 case가 필요합니다. 이 finding도 first-class index 및 domain-base resolution과 함께 #45 Draft에서 먼저 해결하고 transport는 뒤로 유지하십시오.

[seonghobae]

Coordination update: successor #46 now carries first-class index evidence plus shared domain-base resolution, but its current exact head 235ceda8f6d046a989d3955938a62dc67eb5ab09 is intentionally RED after review 5174516003. The new RED proves the index VO can encode contradictory key/INCLUDE roles and non-contiguous pg_index ordinals; #46 must repair that before its index delta can be treated as closing #45's P0. #45's separate relation-kind coordinate defect remains open unchanged. Preserve #45 Draft and stack order; do not transfer #46 predecessor local GREEN or retarget/flatten the stack.

[seonghobae]

Coordination handoff: the three findings previously recorded against this parent (first-class index evidence, domain base-type resolution, and kind-accurate successor relation coordinates) now have ordinary forward source repairs in stacked #46. #46 is exact 033ae72b95e3ef490c47ec84c191b83632601b10, OPEN Draft, with current baseline authority. Its latest lineage additionally closes the impossible empty/INCLUDE-only index-state gap: review 5174770575 -> RED 808faa92... -> constructor/rustdoc repair 6dd59aef... -> baseline 033ae72b... -> exact-current review 5174799976. Keep #45 source stable; do not duplicate the child repair here. Parent adoption is sequenced only after #46 obtains fresh exact-head Rust 1.98 and applicable hosted Product/security/review acceptance, then ordinary/non-force integration preserves both histories.

[seonghobae]

Coordination-only review on unchanged parent 6b2a8f555725dc79f60432afbc492d6005290a4a: child #46 has advanced by ordinary forward history to 503a3c2d273f47a7b73f2eb7284826c5382f5a0a. The prior per-key PostgreSQL semantic RED is source/docs repaired there (173ae2f... production + 503a3c2d... baseline), but exact-head Rust/Product evidence is still absent. Preserve this parent source unchanged; do not duplicate the child implementation. Ordinary/non-force adoption becomes eligible only after #46 has one exact terminal GREEN head.

[seonghobae]

Coordination-only review on unchanged parent 6b2a8f555725dc79f60432afbc492d6005290a4a: current child authority is #46 3a838d7acac79a69b2616fa74d77e3b66f34e013. Child review 5176253356 records source/docs repair for per-key semantics plus operator-class parameters, but exact-head native/Product GREEN is still absent (no PR workflow run; CodeRabbit-only combined status; no pinned Rust toolchain in the current runtime). Preserve the child delta without reimplementation. Do not restack/adopt into this parent until that exact child head is executable GREEN; when it is, use ordinary/non-force integration and regenerate parent evidence.

[seonghobae]

Coordination authority refresh only; parent source remains unchanged. #46 has advanced ordinary-forward to exact 630040b71335b36095b1b10d262888fbb5bebd31. Its pg_index/operator-class/pg_class.reloptions repairs must be preserved. Current child blocker is review 5176975409 -> tablespace RED 1a47d6b16838006e5f7a75407e69464740f368b1; exact-current review 5177051047 records RED-active status. Do not reimplement in #45 or adopt early. Wait for #46 minimal IndexTablespace repair and one unchanged exact-head Rust/Product GREEN, then integrate ordinary/non-force and regenerate #45 acceptance.

[seonghobae]

Coordination-only handoff: child #46 has advanced ordinary-forward to exact eaecb512aeee37eb53f9e5602b5466ab3e2de40d. The prior tablespace RED 1a47d6b... is now source-repaired by 5021ed6b... plus public export b56a38de...; eaecb512... currentizes the canonical baseline. Do not duplicate this child delta here. #46 is still Draft and lacks exact-head Rust/Product GREEN (no PR workflow runs; runtime has no Rust toolchain), so #45 must remain unchanged until the child obtains fresh acceptance, then adopt ordinary/non-force and regenerate parent evidence.

[seonghobae]

Coordination update: child #46 has advanced ordinary-forward from eaecb512... to exact 407434767187474fa7e497040ea2f29bffcd94e2. Preserve the child delta and do not reimplement it here. New review 5177806003 identifies missing index-object pg_class.relkind; RED d425bdfb00652321367dd1fef0c77930d2ade327 now requires ordinary (i) and partitioned (I) indexes to remain distinct v3 identities. 407434767... currentizes the canonical gap baseline. #46 is RED-active, not source/native/Product GREEN. Parent adoption remains blocked until that RED is minimally repaired and one unchanged #46 head obtains exact Rust/Product/security/review acceptance; then adopt ordinary/non-force into this parent.

[seonghobae]

Coordination correction superseding review 5177824466: child #46's provisional index-relkind RED was invalid after deeper PostgreSQL 18 source verification. DefineIndex derives partitioned-index creation from the owning relation's partitioned-table kind and index_create deterministically maps that flag to RELKIND_PARTITIONED_INDEX versus ordinary RELKIND_INDEX. The same partitioned owning relation cannot validly choose both kinds as RED d425bdf... assumed. Child review 5177862263 records the correction; the RED was removed ordinary-forward at 96e2b683ad21ebdd1137f618b6f1d2c56ae544c2; current child is #46 exact 9ed1339e7251f74e423b90cd32c9503c821d53b2, source/docs repaired but still pending exact-head native/Product acceptance. Preserve this corrected child; do not add duplicate IndexRelationKind state in the parent.

[seonghobae]

Fresh child handoff after corrected relkind analysis: #46 is now exact c73659fc5a94419018601407be628bc72ba9cd27. Review 5177885832 identifies a real PostgreSQL schema-local pg_class namespace gap; behavioral RED b820c7b80b6c95e6ae419515882d850d79e578ec requires snapshot construction to reject duplicate index names across two relations in one schema and index/relation name collisions, while allowing the same index name in different schemas. Preserve this child RED and do not reimplement it here. Parent adoption remains blocked until canonicalization repair plus one unchanged #46 head obtains exact Rust/Product/security/review GREEN.

[seonghobae]

Coordination on unchanged parent 6b2a8f555725dc79f60432afbc492d6005290a4a: child #46 has advanced ordinary-forward to a548e7c811ea1037ce20343ac28f549eba8eb1ae. Namespace RED b820c7b... is source-repaired by 1bede235...; a548e7c... only currentizes the canonical baseline. Do not duplicate the child repair in this parent or adopt it before exact-head Rust/Product/security/dependency/review GREEN. Parent remains Draft and unchanged.

[seonghobae]

Current child authority is #46 exact ebaff1d5307c3755b91d991b900cb18dd9bbb024. Preserve the child’s schema-local namespace and index-owner relation-kind repairs; do not duplicate them in this parent. Latest lineage is review 5178743508 -> RED f81ae51 -> production repair a8e9fac -> formatting successor ebaff1d -> exact-current review 5178790507. #46 still has zero PR-triggered workflow runs and only CodeRabbit success, so wait for unchanged exact-head Rust 1.98/Product/security/dependency/review terminal GREEN before ordinary/non-force adoption into #45. No predecessor evidence transfers.

[seonghobae]

Superseding child coordinate after ordinary-forward test formatting: #46 is now exact 9b77f3ff2f7f5cb2a10b233e9228f5885f72b70b. Preserve review 5178743508 -> RED f81ae51... -> repair a8e9fac... and the later formatting-only successors. The child remains Draft with zero PR-triggered workflow runs and CodeRabbit success only. Do not adopt into #45 until this exact successor obtains required Rust/Product/security/dependency/review GREEN; then integrate ordinary/non-force and regenerate parent acceptance.

[seonghobae]

Coordination handoff on unchanged parent 6b2a8f555725dc79f60432afbc492d6005290a4a: current Source Observation repair successor is #46 exact 4826a66a50ef595453d8e2fc139e483334974063. Child lineage 5179341855 -> 089df3d4... RED -> 50b8d05e... source repair -> 4826a66a... baseline/current head -> review 5179398687 adds fail-closed represented constraint ownership by PostgreSQL relation kind. Do not reimplement this child delta here. Keep #45 Draft and adopt #46 ordinary/non-force only after one unchanged #46 head has repository-pinned Rust 1.98 and applicable Product/security/dependency/review GREEN; then regenerate parent exact-head acceptance before passing to #6.

[seonghobae]

Coordination/current-authority review: #46 has advanced ordinary-forward to exact e2a5609cb9e6a7ced73b7069055adf151d8f7db1. Its new relation-backed composite type lineage is review 5180058119 -> RED eca8adb2e5667048c220a37ad863971a8457e9d3 -> source repair 66130c568705092ffd4dabc9bf56bf2a8c88da3a -> baseline currentization e2a5609c..., with exact-current review 5180159464. Preserve this child delta; do not duplicate it in #45. #46 still has zero PR-triggered workflow runs and no exact-head Rust/Product acceptance, so #45 must remain unchanged/Draft until the child obtains real exact-head GREEN, then adopt ordinary/non-force and regenerate parent acceptance.

[seonghobae]

Coordination/current-authority review: active child #46 is now exact fc373bb3cb0e658465d89389bfb08513703065f1, with PostgreSQL true-array identity finding 5180207753, RED 856934e561cf41b9ef546570b9a41524549b57f2, and exact-current RED review 5180249671. Preserve the child delta and do not duplicate it here. #45 remains unchanged/Draft; adoption is allowed only after #46 repairs first-class exact array/element identity and then produces real exact-head Rust 1.98/Product/security/dependency/review GREEN.

[seonghobae]

Coordination checkpoint on unchanged parent 6b2a8f555725dc79f60432afbc492d6005290a4a: current child authority is #46 89e571210336bada5eb033c983c8bf1fd1357464. The PostgreSQL true-array P1 remains child-owned. Finding 5180207753 produced initial RED 856934e5...; verification review 5180344773 found its _status collision fixture omitted the automatic array of that enum; corrected RED 51075e48... now uses catalog-realistic prior true-array occupancy and adds one-element/one-true-array plus no-array-of-array invariants; exact-current child review is 5180370943. Do not duplicate this delta in #45. Keep #45 Draft/unchanged until one repaired #46 exact head is Rust 1.98 + hosted Product/security/dependency/review GREEN, then adopt ordinary/non-force and regenerate parent acceptance.

[seonghobae]

Coordination authority: current child #46 is a0f4766425dae85ffc63a735850455e76fcc7141. Its PostgreSQL true-array P1 is source/docs repaired through ArrayTypeObservation, array-aware admission/digest/receipt regressions and same-schema reciprocity, but exact-head Rust/Product acceptance is still absent. Keep this parent source head unchanged and Draft; do not reimplement the child delta here. Ordinary/non-force adoption starts only after #46 unchanged exact-head GREEN, followed by fresh #45 acceptance before #6 adoption.

[seonghobae]

Coordination update on unchanged parent 6b2a8f555725dc79f60432afbc492d6005290a4a: current repair successor is #46 exact ccd7e245010dab994a6540fe2de5e15db3f742ea. Child review 5180938301 -> RED 65be0a02... -> repair 27de693b... closes v3 admission of multiple primary keys and nullable primary-key columns without changing frozen v2 semantics; code-current baseline is ccd7e245... and exact-current child review is 5180986486. Do not duplicate this delta in #45 or adopt it before the child has unchanged-head native/Product acceptance. Protected/default ConceptWeave main still lacks the repository-local Product workflow bootstrap, so Ready/no-op/manual retriggers are not acceptance. Preserve ordinary/non-force order #46 GREEN -> #45 adoption/fresh acceptance -> #6.

[seonghobae]

Coordination checkpoint: parent source remains intentionally unchanged at 6b2a8f555725dc79f60432afbc492d6005290a4a; current child authority is #46 exact 1ecc9da762f7476d092b3d234d7bc4d15536999e, RED-active for constraint_backing_index_contract after the ordinary-forward PK/UNIQUE timing repair. Do not duplicate this child repair in #45 and do not transfer predecessor GREEN. Required sequence remains child causal repair -> unchanged exact-head Rust/Product/security/dependency/review GREEN -> ordinary/non-force adoption into #45 -> fresh parent acceptance -> #6.

[seonghobae]

Child authority advanced ordinary-forward to #46 acde671903aa244596f045ec4523d13d882b5861; source repair is e96367b2944ce3bb33f2b33be04dd36bb0f84e33 and the child baseline is current at its exact head. Keep this parent source unchanged. Do not duplicate or partially cherry-pick the array/type-kind repair. Adoption remains gated on unchanged-head #46 Rust 1.98/Product/security/dependency/review GREEN, followed by ordinary/non-force adoption and fresh parent acceptance.

[seonghobae]

Coordination checkpoint: parent source remains unchanged at 6b2a8f555725dc79f60432afbc492d6005290a4a. Current child authority is #46 11e40e59f3ab3fa0067c4bf78842166b375d8d2a, carrying the authorized cross-schema type-kind RED c166247..., production repair 050a2ad..., review 5185723369, doctoring d377b3a..., and code-current baseline. Do not duplicate or partially cherry-pick this repair in the parent. Await unchanged-head #46 native/Product/security/dependency GREEN, then adopt the full valid delta ordinary/non-force and reacquire parent acceptance.

[seonghobae]

Child authority refresh only; parent source intentionally unchanged. #46 advanced normally to bfbce8b040a411c89bd9cba3d19b9b5b14a84da6 with active temporal backing-index RED c80d07816863f814e9b8fbb716661310d8b2b150 after finding 5185780899. Do not duplicate the fix here. Required order remains #46 minimal production repair + code-current baseline + unchanged-head acceptance -> full ordinary/non-force adoption into this parent -> fresh parent acceptance -> #6 propagation.

[seonghobae]

Child authority refresh: keep this parent source unchanged. #46 is now exact d7d805a5609190dc6d15d433efb0ea7ecbd95ea0, OPEN/Draft/mergeable, with temporal conexclop semantic repair lineage 5186120516 -> 8b5c3ba... -> 2333d7f... -> 5fa8112... -> ef28937... -> d7d805a... -> 5186129661. The child is source-repaired but has no transferable native/Product GREEN. Required order remains unchanged-head #46 acceptance -> full ordinary/non-force child adoption here -> fresh parent acceptance -> #6 propagation. Do not duplicate or partially cherry-pick the child delta.

[seonghobae]

Coordination checkpoint: child #46 authority advanced ordinary-forward to 7431832546200a4e7ceaf91fae95e4b619ad89db with active P1 behavioral RED for missing referenced temporal-key evidence on outbound PERIOD FKs (5186323924 -> d692773... -> 6ae821d... -> 7431832...). Keep this parent source unchanged; do not duplicate or cherry-pick the child repair. Adoption remains sequenced after the child is causally repaired and one unchanged exact child head obtains native/Product acceptance.

[seonghobae]

Coordination checkpoint: child #46 has advanced ordinary-forward to exact d1605519641367abf49d5ef8265f4ce3d25278ee; production repair 1462105f2ad36a736ebb8263c6e97968490414b2 fail-closes missing referenced-relation authority for positive PERIOD FKs and the child baseline is current. Keep this parent source unchanged and do not duplicate/cherry-pick the child repair. Adoption remains gated on unchanged-head #46 Rust/Product/security/dependency/review GREEN, then complete ordinary/non-force adoption here and fresh parent acceptance.

[seonghobae]

Child authority advanced ordinary-forward to #46 d3c58b0c0722731c7c7ab185446586f0124514a0. New valid P1 is behavioral RED, not parent work: positive WITHOUT OVERLAPS period admission can accept a same-name GiST/exclusion backing index whose ordered key attributes differ from the PK/UNIQUE constraint when timing evidence is absent. Preserve this parent source unchanged; #46 must repair and obtain unchanged-head acceptance first, then this parent adopts the complete child non-force and reacquires fresh acceptance.

[seonghobae]

Final child coordinate for this run is #46 3e45a345afa0c7f41cb54de55b64c2daf657d7dd. The backing-index key-shape P1 is source-repaired at e258b39474454b4c84f51f23dcfb6b00285f4db3; later child commits are doctoring/baseline currentization. Parent remains intentionally unchanged until the child produces unchanged-head Rust/Product/security/dependency/review GREEN, after which adopt the complete child ordinary/non-force and reacquire fresh parent evidence.

[seonghobae]

Source Observation child authority advanced ordinary-forward only for code-current coordination: #46 is now exact 650e77ce1ad92cc0cd1153a9a42126ef9a97f62d after baseline currentization. Production lifecycle P1 is still RED; no source repair or child GREEN exists yet. Keep this parent source unchanged and do not duplicate the fix here. Adoption order remains: repair the shared child backing-index lifecycle predicate -> obtain one unchanged #46 Rust/Product/security/dependency/review GREEN -> adopt the complete child delta ordinary/non-force into #45 -> reacquire fresh parent acceptance.

[seonghobae]

Concurrent coordination currentization: #46 has advanced docs-only again to exact a32f49c2e5cbe3635711347b5f8b7fdf205b2169 after adopting the central #2114 successor advance. The child production lifecycle P1 is still RED and #45 source remains unchanged. Treat prior 650e77ce... coordination as historical; adoption still waits for the shared-predicate source repair and one unchanged child GREEN.

[seonghobae]

Final current coordination for this sweep: #46 is exact 28998888161cf570be79ea17fb0dfd31017f4895, with movement since the active RED limited to authority/baseline currentization. Production lifecycle repair is still pending. Treat earlier child-head coordination comments as historical and keep #45 source unchanged until #46 has the shared-predicate causal repair plus one unchanged exact-head GREEN.

[seonghobae]

Child authority update only; parent source remains unchanged. #46 ordinary-forward authority is now 30b47865ba333a7ded48fdd841fd81348e9c34f3, with active lifecycle-completeness P1 5187402940 -> RED 9d9e8d9e35f008edf0e3359188723dd94db512c8 -> doctoring 77b12263df08f921645e9f9fed66479847228471 -> baseline 30b47865ba333a7ded48fdd841fd81348e9c34f3. The retained ff842b35... repair rejects explicit false lifecycle but still accepts unobserved ready/valid/live through is_none_or; child state is BEHAVIORAL_RED_ACTIVE, not source-repaired. Do not duplicate or partially cherry-pick the child fix here. Required order remains #46 shared-predicate repair (Some(true) for ready/valid/live only when admitted as constraint support) -> unchanged-head GREEN -> complete ordinary/non-force adoption here -> fresh parent GREEN -> #6 propagation.

[seonghobae]

Fresh child coordination only; parent source remains unchanged. #46 is now exact cdb50a49d6abb3101abb9498a88adf7fe0d890e0, with lifecycle-completeness finding 5187402940 / RED 9d9e8d9e... causally repaired by ordinary-forward production commit 384d1305f86c34c17cd40d7594f69e0a102bc26b (ready/valid/live == Some(true) in the shared backing-index predicate) and baseline currentized on cdb50a49.... Child is SOURCE_REPAIRED / ACCEPTANCE_PENDING, not GREEN: zero PR-triggered workflow runs and CodeRabbit-only status remain, and no Rust toolchain is available in the current execution host. Do not duplicate or partially cherry-pick the child repair here. Required order remains unchanged: #46 unchanged-head Rust/Product/security/dependency/review GREEN -> complete ordinary/non-force adoption into #45 -> fresh parent acceptance -> #6 propagation. Central .github#2114@bb183e4d... is a separate owner path and currently has a terminal formal OpenCode review-receipt failure; no central evidence transfers.

[seonghobae]

Child authority update only; keep this parent source unchanged. #46 is now exact 1430947606da7392a9d167a618b07c26c5e84dae, OPEN Draft/mergeable, with active column-collation P1 (5187855669 -> 8006b24f... -> 313f27c... -> 14309476...). The new RED proves Source Observation still lacks column pg_attribute.attcollation + resolved determinism evidence needed both for source identity and PostgreSQL FK collation compatibility. #46 is COLUMN_COLLATION_RED_ACTIVE, not acceptance-pending GREEN: zero PR workflow runs and only CodeRabbit status on the exact head. Do not duplicate or partially cherry-pick the child repair here. Sequence remains: #46 production observed-family/digest/FK repair -> unchanged-head Rust/hosted GREEN -> complete ordinary/non-force adoption into #45 -> fresh #45 GREEN -> #6.

[seonghobae]

Coordination-only review; parent source remains unchanged. Canonical child #46 is now exact 122dfa983ef1c2a9a1f6a68882eb12461243155d, OPEN/Draft/mergeable, with the column-collation P1 source-repaired and edge contracts/doctoring/Gap baseline ordinary-forward. It is SOURCE_REPAIRED / ACCEPTANCE_PENDING, not GREEN: no PR-triggered Rust/Product runs exist on that exact head and the available host has no Rust toolchain. Do not duplicate or partially cherry-pick the child repair here. Required sequence remains #46 unchanged-head terminal GREEN -> complete ordinary/non-force adoption into #45 -> fresh parent acceptance -> #6 propagation.

[seonghobae]

Fresh child coordination: keep this parent source unchanged. #46 has ordinary-forwarded from the prior collation-repair head to exact 89f53ff08c9a1510b04b0207c2f6b10c1af0ed6e and is now COLUMN_IDENTITY_RED_ACTIVE. Review 5188215648 found missing source-authoritative PostgreSQL pg_attribute.attidentity; RED 85f2eb0c... requires explicit not-identity / GENERATED ALWAYS / GENERATED BY DEFAULT material identity, complete bounded column coverage, duplicate rejection, and permutation invariance; doctoring 9bcc5e66... and code-current baseline 89f53ff... carry the boundary. Do not partially cherry-pick or independently implement the child repair here. Required order remains: #46 minimal production repair -> one unchanged exact-head Rust/Product GREEN -> complete ordinary/non-force adoption into #45 -> fresh #45 acceptance -> #6 propagation.

[seonghobae]

Fresh child coordination: keep #45 source unchanged. #46 is now exact da9e20ace19426a3a43d7f9400e034d1361204f7, OPEN Draft/mergeable and COLUMN_IDENTITY_SOURCE_REPAIRED / ACCEPTANCE_PENDING. The child lineage is finding 5188215648, RED 85f2eb0c..., family 69a86d2a..., aggregate integration 95f7f81f..., implementation doctoring 78a52e03..., code-current baseline da9e20ac.... Do not partially cherry-pick or independently reimplement this delta here. Required order remains: one unchanged #46 Rust 1.98 + hosted GREEN -> complete ordinary/non-force adoption into #45 -> fresh #45 acceptance -> #6 propagation.

[seonghobae]

Fresh child coordination: #46 is now exact 7386ffb46ac72fb5257ac2ffd50ef8baab672f5e, OPEN/Draft/mergeable. Its ordinary-forward delta adds the identity/nullability consistency P1 repair after review 5188419794: behavioral regression bd6da911262a70a0a6d27ba439848831062813fb, production 00b166bfb47473b567bef3c5ab2f800327afda34, doctoring 0bba879daec988b15cff63918224d70ff71c7cf6, code-current Gap baseline 7386ffb46ac72fb5257ac2ffd50ef8baab672f5e.

Keep this parent source unchanged. #46 has zero PR-triggered workflow runs on the exact head and only CodeRabbit success; repository-pinned Rust 1.98/native and applicable hosted acceptance are still absent. Do not partially cherry-pick or duplicate the child repair. Required order remains: unchanged #46 exact-head GREEN -> complete ordinary/non-force adoption into #45 -> fresh #45 acceptance -> #6 propagation.

[seonghobae]

Fresh child coordination: keep this parent source unchanged. #46 has ordinary-forwarded to exact 2e2e5abb229c23bf6b7105b20f1fe2bc5ccdf4b9 with a new PostgreSQL 18 pg_attribute.attgenerated P1: finding 5188836578, compile-level RED be3adfd0fa49fe3e27d9794c3773993a48235289, doctoring 4708708c3b9e33a3ec6ef5b49defadfbd5339300, and code-current baseline 2e2e5abb.... Current child state is COLUMN_GENERATION_RED_ACTIVE, not source-repaired/GREEN.

Do not cherry-pick or reimplement this partial child slice here. Required order remains: #46 minimum generation-family repair -> one unchanged exact-head Rust 1.98 + hosted GREEN -> complete ordinary/non-force child adoption into #45 -> fresh #45 acceptance -> #6 propagation.

[seonghobae]

Final child coordinate for this run: #46 is exact 292e996fb45275f120f097c819431b8aaf3ca3c0, OPEN/Draft, COLUMN_GENERATION_RED_ACTIVE. The refined RED lineage is 5188836578 -> be3adfd0fa49fe3e27d9794c3773993a48235289 -> 493e56bc6e985495511ef981e2d765c7d0583b51, with doctoring 4708708c3b9e33a3ec6ef5b49defadfbd5339300 and code-current baseline 292e996f....

Keep #45 source unchanged. No partial adoption before #46 has the minimum generation-family production repair and one unchanged exact-head native/hosted GREEN; then adopt the complete child ordinary/non-force and rerun fresh parent acceptance.

[seonghobae]

Child authority refresh only; do not duplicate source. #46 advanced ordinary-forward to exact 1a8ff08e4751b0cf83831fc6159d878a4945e7c6 and remains COLUMN_GENERATION_RED_ACTIVE. The child now also currentizes the independent central Noema owner RED .github#2079@6ca329896a846110ade7182ed6fa0fa7b0fbba7d. #45 source stays unchanged until #46 receives the generation production repair and one unchanged exact-head native/hosted GREEN set; then adopt the complete child delta ordinary/non-force and re-run parent acceptance.

[seonghobae]

Fresh child coordination: #46 is now exact fb6b0226fb6c4364f9e241bf01b684e110433386, OPEN Draft/mergeable, with the PostgreSQL 18 attgenerated source repair present (32555632... family, f4e8295b... aggregate integration, 8b0c6447... reverse-order regression, d67433cc... doctoring, current baseline fb6b0226...). Child state is SOURCE_REPAIRED / ACCEPTANCE_PENDING, not GREEN: exact-head pull-request workflow runs are still absent and repository-pinned Rust 1.98/native plus hosted Product/security/dependency/review acceptance remain outstanding. Keep this parent source unchanged. Required sequence remains #46 unchanged-head terminal GREEN → complete ordinary/non-force adoption into #45 → fresh #45 acceptance → #6 propagation; no partial cherry-pick or duplicate implementation.

[seonghobae]

Child authority advanced ordinary-forward. #46 is now exact ac590894bfd93297aed1b83859d4745bb5235d40 and is COLUMN_EXPRESSION_RED_ACTIVE, not SOURCE_REPAIRED/GREEN. Finding 5189444945 identified missing governed pg_attrdef default/generation-expression identity; RED afc9509f021681e6f6a2d0e6d0c386cce46fad12 and doctoring 3a76c46bc4d12fac2b8c3407a1d6a09005ddd7ea are retained, and baseline ac590894... is code-current. Keep this parent source unchanged; do not duplicate or partially cherry-pick the child. Required sequence is #46 expression production repair → unchanged-head Rust 1.98/hosted GREEN → complete ordinary/non-force adoption here → fresh #45 acceptance → #6 propagation.

[seonghobae]

Fresh child coordination update: #46 has ordinary-forwarded from the stale fb6b0226... coordinate to exact bd63564fd721072269a50bf5c8dbecc09a30807f. The new head stages the isolated PostgreSQL column-expression production module but deliberately remains COLUMN_EXPRESSION_MODULE_STAGED / AGGREGATE_RED_ACTIVE; root aggregate integration and exact-head native/hosted acceptance are still outstanding.

Keep #45 source unchanged. Do not partially cherry-pick the staged module. Parent adoption remains gated on one unchanged #46 exact head completing aggregate repair and reaching terminal GREEN, then adopt the complete child delta ordinary/non-force and run fresh #45 acceptance.

[seonghobae]

Child authority advanced ordinary-forward: #46 is now exact a41ea7efca0fc19f9fd80e2a9dbf00630d0a1cc1, with column-expression aggregate source repair at 8da6fa3193f9d2191a260372559078bb31f3118a, ordering/precondition regressions at 3b2b6fda8ccab43ce57488ad5fbb76458502af95, and code-current baseline at a41ea7ef.... #46 state is COLUMN_EXPRESSION_SOURCE_REPAIRED / ACCEPTANCE_PENDING, not GREEN: exact head has zero PR-triggered workflow runs and only CodeRabbit status, and Rust 1.98 native acceptance has not executed. Keep this parent source unchanged; do not partially cherry-pick. Adopt the complete child ordinary/non-force only after one unchanged #46 head reaches terminal native/hosted GREEN, then run fresh #45 acceptance.

[seonghobae]

Child authority moved ordinary-forward to #46 675a923d7f8f572fabbd06080f074e902ba3aaaf. Preserve this parent source unchanged. The active child is PostgreSQL 18 NOT NULL constraint MODULE_STAGED / AGGREGATE_RED_ACTIVE; do not partially adopt 8912039b.../91086655... before the aggregate seam and exact-head Rust/hosted acceptance are complete. Required sequence remains #46 unchanged-head GREEN → complete ordinary/non-force adoption here → fresh #45 acceptance → #6 propagation.

[seonghobae]

Coordination handoff only; parent source stays unchanged. Current complete child authority is #46 e36fe671875e24516e8c1666300e735f5607025b, still NOT_NULL_CONSTRAINT_MODULE_STAGED / AGGREGATE_RED_ACTIVE. Preserve the new conparentid parent-kind RED/fix/doctoring lineage together with all earlier child deltas. Do not cherry-pick the small fix alone or reimplement it here. Required order remains #46 aggregate repair -> unchanged-head native/hosted GREEN -> complete ordinary/non-force adoption into #45 -> fresh #45 acceptance -> #6 propagation.

[seonghobae]

Child authority moved ordinary-forward to #46 exact cc6c4af9342384e60004430649725a3d220461a4. Preserve this parent source unchanged. The child now also rejects impossible PostgreSQL pg_constraint.coninhcount values above signed int2 maximum through 28916758... -> 385bf437... -> 1b16ce65..., with current baseline at cc6c4af.... Do not partially cherry-pick or duplicate the fix. Required sequence remains unchanged #46 exact-head native/hosted GREEN -> complete ordinary/non-force child adoption here -> fresh #45 acceptance -> #6 propagation.