docs(plan): correct D-TRI-1 classid spec — cognitive task types are already frozen atoms

.claude/board/EPIPHANIES.md

@@ -19,6 +19,17 @@
 - **What was wrong.** The probe collapsed typed structure — every relation is its own context:role plane — into one weight-summed adjacency, partitioned the blob, and reported a scalar agreement as a decision. Structure ≠ similarity; the `(8:8)`/ClassView substrate exists to enforce exactly that, and the probe violated it *after* the rule had been stated. The "DISTINCT → community-id earns the mint" verdict was retracted; the whole probe line is now removed rather than iterated.
 - **Stands on its own (unaffected):** the context:role traversal-tissue doctrine (`E-CONTEXT-ROLE-TISSUE-1`), the jc-scientific / empirical boundary (`E-EMPIRICAL-VS-SCIENTIFIC-JC-1`), the G0 harness (#716, no jc). The community≡basin identity (`E-GRAPHRAG-DGR3B-1`) is an UNRUN hypothesis again — there is no valid probe for it in-tree.
 - **Rule (operator, reinforced):** no empirical probe of mine sits next to or dev-depends on jc. A community/basin agreement, if ever measured, is decomposed per typed plane and does not borrow jc's adjacency.
+## 2026-07-18 — E-COGNITIVE-ATOMS-ALREADY-FROZEN — the cognitive task types (inference/deduction/induction/abduction/counterfactual/extrapolation/syllogism/synthesis/fan-out) are ALREADY global frozen atoms in `holograph::dntree` — the #719 "Cognition `0x03` ConceptDomain" was a rediscovery-tax error; corrected, byte `0x03` stays reserved, and the only real concept mint in the D-TRI-1 batch is chess `0x06`
+
+**Status:** CORRECTED (spec `.claude/plans/dtri1-classid-mint-spec-v1.md` §2/§2a rewritten this commit; no bytes were ever minted — the #719 spec was a proposal, so this is a pre-mint correction with zero on-chain reclaim). Operator-taught 2026-07-18.
+
+- **The error:** #719 §2 proposed a new `ConceptDomain::Cognition` at byte `0x03` with a `cognitive_<verb>` CODEBOOK block (`cognitive_inference 0x0304`, `cognitive_deduction 0x0305`, …). That duplicated types that **already exist**.
+- **Operator ruling (verbatim):** *"Cognitive atoms and induction abduction synthesis inference deduction extrapolation syllogism are global part of the frozen. They were part of the previous lance-graph PR of the other session if you read them."*
+- **Where they actually live (`crates/holograph/src/dntree.rs`, verified this session):** Epistemic verbs 72–95 — `INFERS=74`, `HYPOTHESIZES=81`, `DEDUCES=82`, `INDUCES=83`, `ABDUCES=84`, `PREDICTS=89`, `EXPECTS=90`; frameworks 0x80–0x8F — `NARS=0x80`, `CAUSALITY=0x83`, `COUNTERFACTUAL=0x84`, `ABDUCTION=0x85`. Syllogism = the shipped NARS `syllogize()` op (`lance-graph-osint` `p5_syllogize`); synthesis + fan-out = orchestration/compose ops, not single atoms.
+- **The corrected model:** a thinking/task row carries **classid = its domain** (chess `0x06`, OSINT `0x07`, …), **task-type = a frozen atom index** in a row lane (`MetaColumn`/triangle), and **thinking-lane materialisation = a read-mode property** (routes to `ValueSchema::Thinking`, §5). No new domain expresses "this is a task." Byte `0x03` stays **unassigned/reserved** (RESERVE-DON'T-RECLAIM — not claimed as a side effect of the correction).
+- **Persona corollary (operator, same ruling):** persona/play-style modeling is **per-consumer opt-in + its own mint**, never a global spine concept. Chess play-style = nice-to-have (a chess consumer may opt in); business consumers (smb-office/woa/medcare) = **NOT business-logic-conform** — no persona lanes on their thinking rows. Matches `I-VSA-IDENTITIES` Layer-2 (persona is a consumer role catalogue, not substrate).
+- **Batch shrinks to one concept mint:** with Cognition removed AND community-id not minting (S1 retracted by #722), the D-TRI-1 batch is **chess `0x06`** (concept) + **BoardAggregates@188** (value tenant, no classid) + the graphrag `D-GR-5` doc-seam classid (other session's).
+- **Process lesson:** the workspace rule "proposing a type that already exists is a 30-turn rediscovery tax — grep the frozen tables first" applies to CODEBOOK concepts as much as to Rust types. `dntree.rs` is the frozen-atom registry; consult it before proposing any cognitive/verb concept. Cross-ref `E-D-TRI-2-MINT-BLOCKED-1` (named the pre-existing `D-TSC-2` "OGAR cognition-domain mint" — now retired as an error), #719 (the spec corrected), #722 (S1 retraction).
 
 ## 2026-07-17 — E-CONTEXT-ROLE-TISSUE-1 — operator ruling: `part_of:is_a` ≡ **context:role**, one polymorphic `6×(8:8)` register with TWO orientations — VERTICAL (stacked exactness = HHTL family identity, q2-FMA-helix-attested) and HORIZONTAL (6-context / episodic-witness `basin:role`, eventual) — reused with classid+appid+ClassView/WideFieldMask as the CONNECTING-TISSUE TRAVERSAL for screens, documents, time series, and AriGraph
 

.claude/board/STATUS_BOARD.md

@@ -22,7 +22,7 @@ Plan: `.claude/plans/triangle-tenants-gestalt-separation-v1.md`. Design shipped;
 
 | D-id | Title | Repo | Status | Evidence |
 |---|---|---|---|---|
-| D-TRI-1 | Triangle tenant spec (Frozen/Learned/Explore, 12 slots x palette256) through envelope-auditor T1-T6, behind the batched mint | lance-graph | **VALUE-TENANT HALF MERGED (#717, main 74d16f92)** — 3 lanes `ValueTenant::{FrozenStyle=10,LearnedStyle=11,ExploreStyle=12}` U8×12 at row_offset 152/164/176; `Full`-only; zero ENVELOPE_LAYOUT_VERSION bump; `NodeRow::{style_lane,set_style_lane,triangle_for}`; auditor LAYOUT-CLEAN; Codex P2 fixed. **classid half = SPEC READY** (`dtri1-classid-mint-spec-v1.md`): chess `0x06` + Cognition `0x03` tasks + BoardAggregates@188 byte-precise, **gated on the other session's S1 (community-id) + the doc-W4 batched-mint council** (never solo). Open knobs: Cognition byte 0x03, BoardAggregates width. | plan §1/§5/§6, `dtri1-classid-mint-spec-v1.md` |
+| D-TRI-1 | Triangle tenant spec (Frozen/Learned/Explore, 12 slots x palette256) through envelope-auditor T1-T6, behind the batched mint | lance-graph | **VALUE-TENANT HALF MERGED (#717, main 74d16f92)** — 3 lanes `ValueTenant::{FrozenStyle=10,LearnedStyle=11,ExploreStyle=12}` U8×12 at row_offset 152/164/176; `Full`-only; zero ENVELOPE_LAYOUT_VERSION bump; `NodeRow::{style_lane,set_style_lane,triangle_for}`; auditor LAYOUT-CLEAN; Codex P2 fixed. **classid half = SPEC READY, CORRECTED 2026-07-18** (`dtri1-classid-mint-spec-v1.md`; `E-COGNITIVE-ATOMS-ALREADY-FROZEN`): the **only real concept mint is chess `0x06`**; the proposed "Cognition `0x03` domain" was a rediscovery error (cognitive task types are already frozen atoms in `holograph::dntree` — INFERS=74/DEDUCES=82/INDUCES=83/ABDUCES=84/COUNTERFACTUAL=0x84/syllogize()), byte `0x03` stays reserved. BoardAggregates@188 = value tenant (no classid). Persona = per-consumer opt-in mint (chess-yes / business-no), not this batch. **Gated on the doc-W4 batched-mint council** (never solo); community-id does NOT mint (S1 retracted by #722). One open knob: BoardAggregates width. | plan §1/§2/§2a/§5/§6, `dtri1-classid-mint-spec-v1.md` |
 | D-TRI-2 | 12-family vs 12-step reading agreement: jc battery (ICC, Pearson/Spearman, Cronbach alpha) over real shader cycles; collapse only on measured identity | lance-graph | Queued | plan §4, §6 |
 | D-TRI-3 | Nail->hammer dispatch probe: object resonance -> atom retrieval vs inverted baseline; no inverted read path exists structurally | lance-graph | Queued | plan §3, §6 |
 | D-TRI-4 | Chess<->thinking transfer measurement (validity + reliability) — the quarantine-lift gate | lance-graph + stockfish-rs | Queued | plan §5, §6 |