Skip to content

3 skills and 11 commands are missing required frontmatter (silently invisible to Claude Code) #6

Description

@YoavLax

Summary

14 files in this repo are silently invisible to Claude Code (and other
AI coding agents) because they are missing required YAML frontmatter, and
there's no automated check that would catch this class of bug before it
ships.

Root cause

Claude Code's Agent Skills
and slash-command formats rely entirely on frontmatter for discovery:

  • A SKILL.md needs name + description in its frontmatter block —
    that's the only signal Claude Code uses to decide when to route to a
    skill. No frontmatter means no discovery, even if the skill body itself
    is complete and well-written.
  • A command file (commands/*.md) needs a description field so it shows
    up correctly in the / command picker.

Three skills and eleven commands in this repo have no frontmatter block at
all (not malformed — just entirely absent):

  • skills/eval-harness/SKILL.md
  • skills/project-guidelines-example/SKILL.md
  • skills/verification-loop/SKILL.md
  • commands/build-fix.md, checkpoint.md, code-review.md, eval.md,
    learn.md, orchestrate.md, refactor-clean.md, test-coverage.md,
    update-codemaps.md, update-docs.md, verify.md

This wasn't caught earlier because:

  1. There's no CI workflow in the repo at all, so nothing runs on push/PR.
  2. There's no root CLAUDE.md, so there's no documented convention/checklist
    for what a new skill or command file requires before being merged.
  3. The other 8 skills and 4 commands do have correct frontmatter, so the
    pattern exists in the repo — it's just not enforced.

How I found this

I ran this repo through AgentCompass,
an open-source, deterministic static analyzer that scores repos on how ready
they are for AI coding agents
(project: https://github.com/YoavLax/agent-compass). It flagged these as
error-level findings (missing required frontmatter fields) with the score:

Score Grade
Before fix 28.68 / 100 F
After fix 71.68 / 100 C

Fix

Resolved in #5, which:

  • Adds the missing name/description frontmatter to the 3 skills and
    description to the 11 commands, matching the pattern already used
    elsewhere in the repo.
  • Adds a root CLAUDE.md documenting the frontmatter requirement.
  • Adds .github/workflows/ci.yml + scripts/validate-frontmatter.js so
    this specific class of bug is caught automatically on every future PR
    instead of silently shipping.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions